Posts Tagged ‘Benefits’
China Business Etiquette
1.Appointment Alert!
•Being late for an appointment is considered a serious insult in Chinese business culture.
•The East Asia & Pacific office of the U.S. Department of Commerce can help you in arranging appointments with local Chinese business and government officials
•and can identify the contacts you will have to establish to achieve your objectives.
•The services of a host of a reputable Public Relations firm is recommended for detailed work involving meeting and negotiating with senior Chinese officials or even pinpointing whom you should meet for your purposes.
•The best times for scheduling appointments are April to June and September to October.
2.Business Dress
•In Chinese business culture, conservative suits and ties in subdued colors are the norm. Bright colors of any kind are considered inappropriate.
•Women should wear conservative suits or dresses; a blouse or other kind of top should have a high neckline. Stick with subdued, neutral, colors such as beige and brown.
•Because of the emphasis on conservative, modest, dress in Chinese business culture, flat shoes or very low heels are the main footwear options for women.
•This is true especially if you are relatively much taller than your hosts. High heels are acceptable only at a formal reception hosted by a foreign diplomat.
•Men should wear suits and ties to formal events; tuxedoes are not a part of Chinese business culture.
•Jeans are acceptable casual wear for both men and women.
•Shorts are reserved for exercise.
•Business and government hours are 9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m., Monday through Friday.
• Do avoid plans to visit government offices on Friday afternoon, because this is sometimes reserved for ‘political studying’ of the officials.
•Store hours are 9:00 a.m. to 9:00 p.m., daily. Most stores in Shanghai, however, remain open until 10:00 p.m.
•Most Chinese workers take a break between 12:00 p.m.- 2:00 p.m. Practically everything “shuts down” during this period, including elevator and phone services.
•When scheduling your appointments, be sensitive to holidays such as Chinese New Year. During May Day, or the National Day, many businesses will be closed for up to a week during this period.
•The date of this occasion varies from year to year due to an official advisory to allow the long holidays.
3.Conversation
•Welcome topics of conversation
•Before your visit, it will be a good idea to prepare yourself by studying aspects of Chinese culture, history, and geography. Your hosts will appreciate your initiative.
•Negative replies are considered impolite.
Instead of saying ‘no’, answer ‘maybe’, ‘I’ll think about it’, or ‘We’ll see’ and get into specifics later.
•You’ll find that the Chinese will do the same. When your Chinese counterparts smilingly and politely or even enthusiastically say ‘No big problem’ or ‘The problem is not serious’, they usually mean ‘There are still problems.
•You may be asked intrusive questions concerning your age, income, and marital status.
•If you don’t want to reveal this information, remain polite and give an unspecific answer.
•Don’t express irritation with the questioner, since ‘losing face’ has such negative implications in this culture. On the other hand, unless you are a very familiar personal friend, do not ask your Chinese hosts about their family
•you can ask ‘How old is your child?’, ‘How long have you been in the work force?’ or ‘Where is your child studying?’ as a means of determining their marital status and age.
•In Chinese culture, the question ‘Have you eaten?’ or ‘Where have you been?’ or ‘Where are you going?’ is the equivalent to ‘How are you?’ in North America;
•Simply answer, ‘yes’, even if you haven’t actually eaten or simply smile and say ‘thank you.’
•Make an effort to learn and use at least a few words in Chinese; your initiative will be noticed and appreciated. Make sure you know the meaning and appropriate occasions for what you say.
•You may make general inquiries about the health of another’s family, such as ‘are all in your family well?’
•During a meal, expressing enthusiasm about the food you are eating is a welcome, and usually expected, topic of conversation. •There is no need to avoid mentioning Taiwan. If the subject comes up, never refer to this island as ‘The Republic of China’ or ‘Nationalist China.’ The correct term is ‘Taiwan Province’, or just ‘Taiwan.’
•’Small talk’ is considered especially important at the beginning of a meeting; any of the topics suggested in the next set of points will be appropriate for this occasion.
Welcome Topics of Conversation
•Chinese scenery, landmarks
weather, climate, and geography in China
•your travels in other countries
•your positive experiences traveling in China
•Chinese art
Topics to Avoid
•Refrain from using the terms such as ‘Red China’,and ‘Communist China.’
•Just say ‘China.’
4.First Name or Title?
•Chinese names appear in a different order than Western names. Each person has, in this order, a family, and first name. •Most people should be addressed with a title and their last name. If a person does not have a professional title, use “Mr.”, “Madam”, “Miss”, plus the last name.
A married Chinese woman usually retains her maiden name; she will use her husband’s last name on occasions for formal addressing only.
Many Chinese adopt an English first name to make it easier for North Americans and other Westerners to address them. You can expect to hear some rather odd and rare English names as they try hard to be different from others.
•Address people using official titles such as “General” “Committee Member”, or “Bureau Chief” whenever possible.
•It is customary to address the deputies by skipping the word ‘deputy,’ such as, ‘Chief’ for ‘Deputy Chief,’ ‘Chairman’ for ‘Vice Chairman’ ‘General Manager’ for ‘Assistant General Manager.’
•Unless you’re a Communist, never refer to someone as “Comrade.”
5.Gift Giving
•Lavish gift giving was an important part of Chinese culture in the past. Today, official policy in Chinese business culture forbids giving gifts; this gesture is considered bribery.
•In many organizations, however, attitudes surrounding gifts are beginning to relax. In any case, you will have to approach giving gifts with discretion.
•If you wish to give a gift to an individual, you must do it privately, in the context of friendship, not business. The Chinese will decline a gift three times before finally accepting, so as not to appear greedy. You will have to continue to insist.
•Once the gift is accepted, express gratitude. You will be expected to go through the same routine if you are offered a gift. •In the presence of other people, never present a valuable gift to one person. This gesture will cause only embarrassment, and possibly even problems for the recipient, given the strict rules against bribery in Chinese business culture.
• Do not take any photograph of any gift giving unless it is a symbolic gift presented to the organization as a whole.
•Giving a gift to the entire company, rather than an individual, can be acceptable in Chinese business culture as long as you adhere to the following rules:
•All business negotiations should be concluded before gifts are exchanged.
•Specify that the gift is from the company you represent. If you can, explain the meaning of the gift to the receiver.
•Present the gift to the leader of the Chinese negotiating team.
•Do not get anything that is obviously expensive, so that the company will not feel obliged to reciprocate.
•Valuable gifts should be given to an individual only in private and strictly as a gesture of friendship.
•Make sure that the gifts given to people of the same level of importance are equitable or of similar grade.
•Do not wrap a gift before arriving in China, as it may be unwrapped in Customs.
•If possible, have your gifts wrapped in red paper, which is considered a lucky color.
•Pink and gold and silver are also acceptable colors for gift wrap.
•Because colors have so many different meanings in this culture, your safest option is to entrust the task of gift-wrapping to a store or hotel that offers this service.
• A good cognac, or other fine liqueur
• A fine pen [not a pen with red ink--writing in red ink symbolizes severing ties]
•solar calculators
•kitchen gadgets
•stamps, if the recipient is interested in them [stamp collecting is very popular here]
•a cigarette lighter, assuming the recipient is a smoker
•Often, gifts are not opened in the presence of the giver.
•Acceptable gifts for a company include items from your country or city, such as handicrafts, or an illustrated book. Be sure to bring a supply of these items with you, so that you can reciprocate if it happens that you are presented with a gift.
•A banquet is usually a welcome gift; since it’s likely you will be invited to one, you will have to follow Chinese business protocol and reciprocate. In some parts of China, senior local officials host the welcoming party
•Gifts of food are acceptable, but not at dinner parties or other occasions where appetizers and meals will be served. Candy and fruit baskets, however, are acceptable as thank-you gifts sent after these events.
•Eight is considered one of the luckiest numbers in Chinese culture. If you receive eight of any item, consider it a gesture of good will.
•Six is considered a blessing for smoothness and problem free advances.
•Four is a taboo because it means ‘death.’ ,especially in Guangdong Province and Hong Kong.
•Other numbers such as ‘73′ meaning ‘the funeral’ and ‘84′ meaning ‘having accidents’ are to be avoided.
Gifts to Avoid
•Scissors, knives, or other sharp objects can be interpreted as the severing of a friendship or other bond. As a gesture of friendship
• if you do want to give these items as a gift, ask your friend to give you a very small amount of money, such as 10 cents or One RMB in return for this gift. By doing so, you would have ’sold’ it to him rather than given it to him.
•The following items are to be avoided as they are associated with funerals:
Straw sandals
clocks
handkerchiefs
four of any item [the Cantonese word for “four” sounds similar, in the same language, to “death”]
•gifts or wrapping paper in white, black, or blue
6. Let’s Make a Deal! – Part 1
•You’ll find it beneficial to bring your own interpreter, if possible, to help you understand the subtleties of everything being said during meetings.
•Speak in short, simple, sentences free of jargon and slang. Pause frequently, so that people will be able to understand everything you’ve said.
•You will have to make presentations to different levels of the organization.
•Before you arrive, have at least 20 copies of your proposal ready for distribution.
•Printed presentation materials of any kind should be only in black and white.Avoid colors that are attributed special meanings in this culture, many of them negative.
•Generally, the Chinese treat “outside” information with caution.
•Except for those educated in the West, Chinese businesspeople largely rely on subjective feelings and personal experiences in forming opinions and solving problems.
•Belief in the Communist party line will be a dominant influence in all negotiations.
•Empirical evidence and other objective facts will be accepted only if they do not contradict Communist party doctrine and one’s feelings.
•In this country, responsibility for all decisions rests with the Communist party and assorted government bureaucrats.
•Individuals working within this network, however, are still accountable for their own actions.
•Local decisions are made by the head of the collective.
•In Chinese business culture, the collectivist way of thinking still prevails, even in sectors experimenting with free enterprise.
•“Saving face” is an important concept to understand. In Chinese business culture, a person’s reputation and social standing rests on this concept. Causing embarrassment or loss of composure, even unintentionally, can be disastrous for business negotiations.
•The Chinese are very keen about exchanging business cards, so be sure to bring a plentiful supply. Ensure that one side is in English and the other is in Chinese, preferably in the local dialect.
•Include your professional title on your business card, especially if you have the seniority to make decisions. In Chinese business culture, the main point of exchanging business cards is to determine who will be the key decision-makers on your side.
•If your company is the oldest or largest in your country, or has another prestigious distinction, ensure that this is stated on your card.
•It’s an asset to have your business cards printed in gold ink. In Chinese business culture, gold is the color of prestige, prosperity.
Let’s Make a Deal! – Part 2
•Present your card with two hands, and ensure that the Chinese side is facing the recipient.
•When receiving a business card, make a show of examining it carefully for a few moments; then, carefully place it into your card case or on the table, if you are seated at one.
•Not reading a business card that has been presented to you, then stuffing it directly into your back pocket, will be a breach of protocol.
•people are expected to enter the meeting room in hierarchical order. For example, the Chinese will assume that the first foreigner to enter the room is head of the delegation.
•Since there is such a strong emphasis on hierarchy in Chinese business culture, ensure that you bring a senior member of your organization to lead the negotiations on your behalf. The Chinese will do the same.
•Only the senior members of your group are expected to lead the discussion. Interruptions of any kind from subordinates are considered shocking by the Chinese.
•In Chinese business culture, humility is a virtue. Exaggerated claims are regarded with suspicion and, in most instances, will be investigated.
•The Chinese will not directly say “no” to you. Instead, ambivalent answers such as “perhaps”, “I’m not sure”, “I’ll think about it”, or “We’ll see” usually mean “no.”
•The Chinese tend to extend negotiations well beyond the official deadline to gain advantage. On the final day of your visit, they even may try to renegotiate everything.
•Be patient, show little emotion, and calmly accept that delays will occur. Moreover, do not mention deadlines.
•At the end of a meeting, you are expected to leave before your Chinese counterparts.
•You may have to make several trips to China to achieve your objectives. Chinese businesspeople prefer to establish a strong relationship before closing a deal.
•Even after the contract is signed, the Chinese will often continue to press for a better deal.
Prosperous Entertaining – Part 1
•Entertaining for business success
•Business lunches are growing in popularity here. Business breakfasts, however, are not a part of Chinese business culture, except in Guangdong, Hangzhou and Fujian province where the ‘Morning Tea’ is very popular.
•Evening banquets are the most popular occasions for business entertaining. Generally, these events start between 5:30 p.m.-6:00 p.m. and last for two hours. If you are the guest, you should arrive on time.
•If you wish, arrive around 15 minutes early to a banquet; your Chinese hosts and counterparts will probably be present before the proceedings officially begin.
•Banquets are hosted with varying degrees of extravagance, usually in a restaurant.
•Wait to be seated, as there is a seating etiquette based on hierarchy in Chinese business culture.
Generally, the seat in the middle of the table, facing the door, is reserved for the host. The most senior guest of honor sits directly to the left. Everyone else is seated in descending order of status. The most senior member sits in the center seat. Follow this seating pattern if you are hosting a banquet or a meal in your residence, whether for business or purely social reasons.
•The host is the first person at the table allowed to begin eating by declaring the first toast. Then, the rest of the company can proceed with the meal. If you are the host, take the first piece of the most valued food and put it on your guest of honor’s plate after the first toast. This will signify that eating can proceed and is considered a friendly gesture.
•Business is not discussed during the meal.
•It is not uncommon for a host to order enough food for ten people at a table of five. He or she loses face if there are not plenty of left-overs at the end of a meal. Rice, considered by many Chinese to be filler, is generally not served until the end of a meal. So, if you want to eat rice with your meal be sure to ask the waitress [or 'shou jie'] to serve it early, particularly if the food is spicy.
•During a meal, as many as 20-30 courses can be served, so try not to eat too much at once. The best policy is to lightly sample each dish.
•Leaving a ‘clean plate’ is perceived to mean that you were not given enough food–a terrible insult here. On the other hand, leaving a food offering untouched will also give offense; even if you find a dish unappealing, try a small portion for the sake of politeness.
•One important part of Chinese business entertaining is a tea drinking ritual It is used to establish rapport before a meeting or during meals.
•If you do not want a ‘refill’ of tea, leave some in your cup.
•If you are served food that does not require utensils, you may be given a bowl of tea for the purpose of dipping and cleaning your fingers.
•It’s perfectly acceptable to reach in front of others for dishes and other items.
•Seeds and bones are placed on the table or in a specially reserved dish; never place these objects in your bowl.
•It will be appreciated if you use chopsticks. When you are finished eating, place your chopsticks on the table or a chopstick rest.
•Placing your chopsticks parallel on top of your bowl is believed to bring bad luck.
•Sticking your chopsticks straight up in your rice bowl is considered rude because in this position, they resemble the joss sticks that are used in Chinese religious rituals.
•Do not put the end of the chopstick in your mouth.
•Try not to drop your chopsticks, as this is considered a sign of bad luck.
Prosperous Entertaining – Part 2
•When eating rice, follow Chinese custom by holding the bowl close to your mouth.
•Scorpions, locusts, snake skin, bile, dog meat, soft-shell tortoise and blood are considered delicacies.
•Toothpicks are usually offered between courses and at the conclusion of a meal. When using a toothpick, cover your mouth with your free hand for concealment.
•Forming a personal relationship ['guanxi' in Chinese] in your business dealings is very important.
•Part of this involves participating in the strong drinking culture that exists here. Generally, the Chinese regard with suspicion anyone who does not participate in the inevitable drinking that takes place during almost all business dinners. And it is at these kinds of social occasions that most negotiating breakthroughs are made..
•Prepare some medical excuses for yourself to avoid drinking heavily
•Toasting, usually with beer, wine or Chinese white liquors, is an important part of Chinese business etiquette.
•You will often find three glasses on your table: a glass for your drink of choice [toast with this glass], a wine glass, and a shot glass for a liquor called ‘maotai’ or ‘wu liang ye.’
•The host of a banquet offers the first toast. If you prefer not to drink alcohol, it’s perfectly acceptable to toast with a soft drink, glass of juice, or mineral water.
•Toasts will be proposed throughout the meal. Two popular toasts are ‘ganbei’ ['bottoms up!'] and ‘kai wei’ ['starting the appetite!'].
•Sometimes, the Chinese enjoy testing the ability of a foreigner ['lou wai'] to handle his or her alcohol, A good practice would be to eat something beforehand.
•Before smoking, it’s polite to offer cigarettes to those in your company.
•The meal has reached a definite conclusion when fruit is served and hot towels are presented. Shortly after these items are offered, guests should make preparations to leave.
•In accordance with Chinese business etiquette, the host will not initiate the guests’ departure.
•Tipping is generally considered an insult in China. Most government operated hotels and restaurants prohibit acceptance of tips. It is sometimes expected, however, in some of the bigger hotels and by younger service personnel, in the more open cities.
•Follow Chinese business protocol and reciprocate with a banquet of the same value; never surpass your host by arranging a more lavish gathering.
•Generally, the Chinese are not great experimenters when it comes to their diet. Unless he or she has traveled extensively, the typical Chinese businessperson doesn’t like Western food. Better to take your guests to a good Chinese restaurant rather than, for example, the latest French restaurant opening in Beijing. They’ll appreciate it.
•If you are hosting a banquet, you should arrive at least 30 minutes before your guests.
•Home entertaining is very popular in China. If you are invited to a Chinese home, you will probably be asked to remove your shoes. Arrive on time, but not too early.
•When inviting people to your home, avoid serving cheese: it is usually incompatible with the national diet.
Public Behavior
Acceptable public conduct
•The Chinese will sometimes nod as an initial greeting. Bowing is seldom used except in ceremonies. Handshakes are also popular; wait, however, for your Chinese counterpart to initiate the gesture. If you visit a school, theater, or other workplace, it is likely that you will be greeted with applause as a sign of welcome. In turn, you should respond by applauding back.
•Avoid making expansive gestures and using unusual facial expressions.
•The Chinese do not use their hands when speaking, and will only become annoyed with a speaker who does.
•Some hand gestures, however, are necessary. They are outlined in the next two points.
•To summon attention, turn your palm down, waving your fingers toward yourself. Use your whole hand rather than your index finger to point.
•The Chinese, especially those who are older and in positions of authority, dislike being touched by strangers.
•Acknowledge the most senior person in a group first.
•Members of the same sex may hold hands in public in order to show friendliness. Public displays of affection between the sexes are frowned upon. Do not put your hands in your mouth, as it is considered vulgar. Consequently, when in public, avoid biting your nails, removing food from your teeth, and similar practices.
•Pushing and cutting ahead is common in lineups among Chinese, but they do not appreciate being cut in front of themselves.Spitting in public is no longer acceptable. It is subject to a heavy fine now.
• Blowing your nose with a handkerchief is also acceptable, but it is advisable to turn away from people while doing so.
Business In China
Business In China
Dr. Zhiwen Liu
College of Economics and Management, Southwest University
1.China Key Information
•Country
Name: People’s Republic of China
Area: 9.6 million sq.km (mainland)
Population: 1.28 billion
Capital city: Beijing (population 13.8 million)
National Language: Chinese (Mandarin)
•Government:
Communist republic
Head of State: President Hu Jintao
•GDP
growth : 9.3% (2004 actual)
Total Gross Domestic product (GDP) for the country is $4.5 trillion (2000
est.) based on purchasing power parity). Per capita GDP based on purchasing
power parity is $3,600 (2000 est.)
Land
•China
is the world’s fourth largest country (after, Russia, Canada and the U.S.)
and the seventh largest economy. China is about the same size as the
continental 48 states (U.S. excluding Hawaii and Alaska). Much of the land
is mountainous or unsuited to agriculture.
Population
The population tends to be predominantly in the east and along the three
major river valleys. Population is huge compared to the U.S., 1.3 Billion
people, over 25 percent of the world’s total—family planning policy.
Government
•The
government is controlled by the Communist Party –cooperate with 8
democratic political parties.
•The
national government is headed up by a President – Hu Jintao and with a
Prime Minister – Premier Wen Jiabao and a Congress—the People’s
Representatives and the Committee of People’s Political Coordination.
Capital–Beijing
•Beijing
is the capital city and home of a brand-new airport to open in 1999.
The Airport is about 30 minutes by taxi from the city center. Beijing’s
population is currently around 10.5 million.
•Other
large Chinese cities are Shanghai – 7.4 million, Guangzhou – 5.5
million, Chonqing – 10 million and Wuhan – 7 million.
People and Languages
•People:
Han Chinese (93%), plus 55 ethnic minorities
•Different
people has different customs.
•Languages:
China’s official language is Mandarin. The Chinese call it
Putonghua . Cantonese is spoken in Guangdong, southern Guangxi, and
Hong Kong
Religion
•Religion:
Confucianism, Buddhism, Taoism (no stats available); Muslim (14
million), Christian (7 million)
Currency
•Currency
is the Yuan (also called the Kwai)
–
approximate exchange rate is 8.25 Yuan = one U.S. dollar.
• Largest
note
in general circulation is 100 Yuan which is roughly about $12.
Natural Resources
Natural Resources in China include coal, iron ore,
petroleum, natural gas, mercury, tin, tungsten, antimony, manganese,
molybdenum, vanadium, magnetite, aluminum, lead, zinc, uranium, hydropower
potential (world’s largest).
agricultural products
he main agricultural products are rice, wheat, potatoes,
sorghum, peanuts, tea, millet, barley, cotton, oilseed, pork, fish.
Major exports and import
Major exports are machinery and equipment; textiles and
clothing, footwear, toys and sporting goods, mineral fuels, and chemicals
Major imports are machinery and equipment, plastics,
chemicals, iron and steel, mineral fuels.
Major industries: Iron, steel, coal, machinery, textiles
Major trading partners: USA, Japan, Germany, South Korea
Chinese Major Es
xports and Imports
Chinese Major
Major Holidays
January 1-2: New Years
Day Holiday
February 24: Chinese New Year
March 8: International Womens Working
Day
April 4-5: Qingming Festival
May 1-2: International Labor Day
May 4: Youth Day
June 1: Childrens Day
June 6: Tuen Ng Festival
July 1: Anniversary of
the Founding of the Communist Party
August 1: Anniversary of the founding
of the Chinese PLA (Peoples Liberation Army)
Sept. 12: Mid-Autumn Festival
October1-2: National Day
Asia
Asia is home to two of the World’s fastest growing
economies: China and India, each with more than 1 billion in population.
Asia, however, is much more than either of these countries
and area with large trading partners like Japan, Korea, Taiwan and
increasingly Southeast Asia (home to over 500 million) continuing to develop
their economies and trade possibilities.
Additionally, many of the trade barriers such as high import
tariffs are disappearing or being greatly reduced throughout the region.
Asia is currently the site of the World’s most active Free
Trade Agreement environment with Thailand and Singapore both noted for their
recent rapid progress in this area and now with China a significant player
in the field as well.
Long –Term Dimensions
China has been the world’s largest manufacture for at least
3600 of last 4000 years.
In 1820,China represented 36% of world GDP, compared to 32%
foe USA ,Now 6%.
In 1979,Deng Xiaoping introduced the first rational economic
policies
Initiated a 23year process of 6-14% annual GDP growth.
Average 9% growth.
Chinese GDP has grown 4 to 5 times in 23years.
Economic data
Demographics
Total children per female in lifetime
–1950s 5.88
–1960s 5.68
—1970s 4.01
—1980s 2.48
–1990s 1.98
Work Force Composition(2002)
Children (not work force ) 22.4%
15—64 (60) 70.3%
-NBS Statistics
65years or older 7.3%
Younger worker(21-40) 35%
Older worker(41-60) 35%
–IMF Statistics
2.Factors of Sustainable Growth
Demographics and work force composition
Benign geo-political environment
Stable monetary and fiscal policy
High savings and investment rates
Rapid adoption of technology
Trend toward market-oriented legislation
Booming private sector
Market depth-strategic range
Foreign Direct Investment (FDI)
Benign External Environment
China is one of five permanent members of U.N. Security
Counsel,with vote rights
Beijing Olympics of 2008
Economic integration on regional basis,despite economic
weakness across 14 borders.
Proposed China-ASEAN FTA
Expanded use of RMB throughout region
Quiet resolution of all major territorial disputes.
2.1 High Investment and domestic Savings Rates
Gross domestic savings/GDP
1981 32%
1991 38%
2000 39%
2001 40%
2002 42%
Gross domestic investment/GDP
1981 32%
1991 35%
2000 36%
2001 38%
2002 40%
Funding source-fixed assets
Source Growth
-State Budget 3.2
-Domestic loans 45.3
-Bonds -24.9
Foreign investment 28.6
Enterprise 46.6
stocks -10.3
Others 40.1
Proportion
5.3
23.6
0.3
4.8
48.0
0.2
18.0
Over Investment In F-asset
Category Increase%
Primary Indus. 10.8
Manu. 51.5
Services 24.4
Real Estate 32.0
Nat.Total 29.6%
Proportion %
2.8
35.6
61.6
34.5
100%
Aggregate foreign Investment
Stock of foreign investment is about $440b or 40% of
GDP—compared to 1.2% in Japan.
Foreign investment accounts for 10% of total capital
expenditures,11% of total production,28% of total manufacturing and 54%
exports in 2002.
FDI leads to rapid productivity growth.
2.2 Rapid Adoption of Technology
2 million college graduates/year v.s. 1.3m in USA
80million internet users
280 million mobile telephone users—112 million new phone
users in 2003
An astronaut into orbit and active space program.
First functioning Magnetic Levitation Train
2.3 Market-Oriented Regulation Increases Competition
Transition from planning economy to market economy(market
economy country position)
95% of consumer goods priced by market;
83% of agricultural goods and 85% producer goods
Reduction of tariffs to 10%,elimination of quotas and
reduction of licensing requirements by 2005
Government/Party/Military is withdrawing from corporate
management role. But crony capitalism is alive and well.
WTO helps to codify market-oriented regulations, but most of
these reforms are aimed at improving domestic productivity. Manufacturing
productivity goes up 12.5% in 2003
Level of Affluence
2002 China Statistics year book
Urban
Car 0.88%
M.cycle 22%
W.machines 92.9%
Color TV 126%
PC 20.6%
Shower 64%
E.Cooking Ap. 96%
Telephone 93.6%
Rural
M.cycle 21.9%
W.machines 28.5%
Color TV 48.7%
Camera 3.1%
Refrigerator 12.3%
Engel Coefficient
Urban
-1978 57%
-1995 48%
-2002 37%
-2004 37.7%
Rural
67%
59%
46%
47.2%
Income per capita per year(2004)
Urban
$1177
6.8%
Rural
$367
7.7%
2004 Imports and exports(0.1b)
2.4 Strategic Depth
Traditional, Labor-intensive industries can continue to
thrive by migrating to inward, poorer provinces, rather than migrating out
to other countries
170 million rural under-employed
China can simultaneously maintain Labor-intensive industries
while transitioning to knowledge and capital-intensive industries.
But from where will the investment come?
2.5 Private Enterprises is Booming
The Communist party recognizes role of private sector and is
cooperating capitalists into party.
1989 only 90,000 firms, in 2000 up to 2 million.
Employment growth is all from private initiative
China has only 20 years experience with private ownership.
There is enormous scope for private firms to expand.
3.Micro Economic Trends
SOE reform continues
State intends to sell of strategic shares
Not Privatization, rather Corporate-lization
Opportunistic conglomeration by SOEs
Nonetheless, productivity is surging in 03:
Ag. 2.5%;Manu.12.5%; Services 6.7%
Definition of private
30years ago private enterprise was illegal.
Definition of private is unlear.
In 2002,as a percentage of production:
-25% State owned enterprises
-21% Collective
-19% Shareholding Co.
-18% Foreign investment enterprises
-17% Private
4. Economic Challenges
Unemployment Rural Migration
Over supply Bad debt
Poor legal environment Corruption
Strengthening the financial system
Pollution control and lack of water
Electric power demand shortage
4.1 poor legal Infrastructure
Domestic protectionism between provinces or cities remain a
difficult barrier.
Contracts are difficult to enforce
Cost of litigation is very high ;penalties are low
Continued barrier in cultural and other service industries
,some sanctioned by WTO
Special problems with intellectual property rights
enforcement: trademarks, patents and copyrights.
4.2 Corruption
Corruption is common at all levels of commerce
American companies must comply with the Foreign Corruption
Act.
FCPA can lead to short term disadvantages relative to
international competition.
Over the longer term, the law probably reduces costs and
increases profitability for American firms operating in China.
4.3 Over supply and bad loans
88% of goods are in over supply, due to excess capacity and
low domestic demand.
Over capacity produces bad loans, at least 15% of total
loans are non-performing.
Lack of bankruptcy law discourages corporate exits and
continue excessive production.
Government ‘s response is to try to increase domestic
demand-housing, automobile, services.
5.WTO Compliance Problems
Intellectual Property Protection
– weak enforcement
–high thresholds for criminal prosecution
–low administrative fines
TRANSPARENCY
--Difficult to obtain draft regulations
Standards
–aggressive development of indigenous standards: TDSCDMA
Trade remedies
– anti-dumping cases
–Subsidy issues
Services
-Strict licensing requirements
-High capitalization requirements
sole proprietorship no minimum capital
LLC
production or wholesale $62,500
retail $40,000
services $12,000
C Corporations $1.2 Million
WTO Schedule for 05
Telecommunications
Financial services
–banking, insurance, securities
Trading rights Retail, wholesale, agents ,services,
franchise, direct sales
Construction, Packaging, Entertainment
Further drop in tariffs, exp. agricultural.
Doing Business In Beijing
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|||||
|
|
|||||
|
|
|
|
|||||||||||||
|
|
|||||||||||||
|
||||||
|
||||||
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
In the May of 1998, the State Development Planning I The Registered Capital: 1.2 hundred million Yuan RMB Registered Location: the No. 19 of Xisi Yangrou The Running Water General Co. of Beijing is a larger 2.The Assignee of Management Rights: Beijing Holding Registered Location: Hong Kong On the 29th of May of 1997, Beijing Holding Co. Ltd. II The Purpose The Stage One Project Of Beijing The 9th Water Factory With better operations, the equipments of the stage one The total investment of the stage 3 project of the 9th III The Modes During the transferring management rights, the IV The Influence on The Sale Price of Water of The V Assuming The Due to the products of the Water Factory are completely At present, Beijing Holding Company has established a |
|
|
|
|
Beijing has established
cooperation relations with 27 sister cities all over the world…
|
|
City |
Country |
Date of Sister City |
||||
|
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
|
INTERVIEW WITH MAYOR OF WEIHAI, SHANDONG, CHINA

Question 1. Can you tell us a little about your city in terms of location in China, population, standard of living, industries, etc?
Answer: Weihai is in Shandong province of China and is located on the east end of Shandong Peninsula. Being on the same latitude as San Francisco in the United States, Weihai is surrounded by sea on three sides, facing Liaoning Penisula to the north and the Korean Peninsula and the Japan Islands to the east. It is the “doorway” to Beijing and Tianjin, thus bearing the name of “coastal front of China”
Weihai has a population of 2.5 million and a total area of 5400 square kilometers. As one of the most developed areas in north China, Weihai achieved a GDP of $8 billion and GDP per capita of $3,070 in 2001, which was the highest in Shandong Province and the same as that of Beijing.
There are four major industries in Weihai:
1. Marine aquaculture and fishery: Weihai is China’s largest base for marine aquaculture and fishery. This accounts for 25% of the City’s GDP.
2. Industrial and agricultural manufacturing: There are more than 10,000 small and medium sized companies that are engaged in industrial and agricultural manufacturing. Weihai is the largest manufacturing base for products such as tires, auto crankshafts, carpets, fishing tackle and carpenter machinery. In addition, Weihai is well known for manufacturing high-speed fax, printing machines, fiber-optical cable, polymer medical appliances, airport equipment, leather shoes, agricultural vehicles and fruit processing.
3. Tourism: Wehai is known throughout China as one of China’s premier tourist cities. Weihai has a lot of scenic spots and historical sites and received about 8 million tourists in 2002. It is extremely popular for tourism during summer time and boasts huge potential for tourism development.
4. Imports and exports: Weihai is one of the earliest trade ports in northern China. It has linking shipping service with major ports in northern China such as Tianjin, Qingdao and Dalian Ports. Additionally, Weihai has cargo and passenger ship service internationally to South Korea, Japan, Hong Kong, etc.
Question 2. How does your city compare to other Chinese cities in terms of economic development, unemployment, educational qualification of the workforce, average wages, GDP per capita and other basic measures of economic success?
Answer: Being one of the 50 cities that have the strongest economy in China, Weihai’s GDP and local government tax revenues have been growing at an average rate of 18.2% and 23.3% respectively in the past 15 years.
Since Weihai does not have a lot of state-owned companies, it has a very small number of people who are unemployed. In year 2002, the total unemployment rate is 1.7% as compared with the average unemployment rate of 3.9% across China.
Thanks to the city’s strong educational tradition, Weihai’s high school students have achieved the highest scores in national college entrance exams consecutively in Shandong province for the past 9 years. In Weihai, there are Harbin Polytechnic University (Weihai), Shandong University Weihai Campus, One Higher Vocational Institute and Higher Technical College. There are also 20 foreign language schools and many other educational training centers. Each year, there are over ten thousand university or college graduates and ten thousand graduates from vocational schools. Virtually all employees have graduated from High School or higher. As a result, Weihai boasts a high quality work force and its productivity has ranked first place in Shandong province consecutively for the past 14 years.
Finally I would like to note that Weihai has the highest income of urban residents and farmers in Shandong province in 2001. This prosperity adds to the city and has helped to reinforce the city’s livability.
Question 3. What are the major industries in your city and which sectors of business do you feel that Weihai companies both have demonstrated their ability to compete and their cost advantages vis-à-vis other areas in China? Also which new sectors do you for see generating the most growth in the years ahead?
Answer: Marine aquaculture and fisheries, auto parts industry, tourism and biotech production are currently are our key industries. We see bio-tech and the high-tech industries as being further future engines of growth.
Question 4. If you were to give five reasons for a company to consider establishing a factory or a business office in your city, what would those reasons be?
Answer:
1) Livability, clean and beautiful environment, golfing (Weihai has four of these) and other recreational sports near beaches.
2) Close to the developed economies and markets such as Japan and South Korea in North Asia
3) International ports, convenient marine transportation and convenient air access via two neighboring airports
4) Two well-known Chinese universities have two huge campuses near beaches, providing talents and trained professionals,
5) Well trained leaders at the municipal government. The city has several leaders who have studied or worked in North America.
Question 5. Weihai is located in Shandong province and I know that Shandong is a leader in both agriculture and the fishing industry in addition to having a large and well developed manufacturing base, are both the fishing and agriculture industries also important to Weihai and has Weihai used its connections through its distribution system for both industries to help serve as an export gateway to import overseas food and other items to China?
Weihai has imported a lot of production equipment from the United States and Europe and is planning to distribute salmon, tuna and other seafood to Beijing and Shanghai via its vast sales network across the country.
Question 6. I understand that your city has developed or is in the advanced planning stages of developing several incubators to help promote new industries in Weihai. Could you tell us about these incubators and your plans for new innovative means of growing new companies?
Answer: We have two incubators in Weihai right now. One is run and sponsored by the government, the other is run by a private company. Both will provide free offices for three years if the high-tech project meets the necessary qualifications. So far we have about 50 start-up companies in the incubators. With the completion of another 15000 square meters of space, we are poised to accept more start-up companies this year. An example of this is San Diego based Genway, a biotech company, that is going to move its antibody production center to the incubator in the next three months. We expect more biotech companies will move a portion of their production function to Weihai when our life science park is established here shortly.
Question 7. Your city has been named for several years as one of the 500 most livable cities in the world by the United Nations. Because of the quick pace of industrialization in China, “livable” is not a term often used to describe China’s major cities. What are the factors that make your city so suitable as a place to live and work?


Question 1. Can you tell us a little about your city in terms of location in China, population, standard of living, industries, etc?
Answer: Weihai is in Shandong province of China and is located on the east end of Shandong Peninsula. Being on the same latitude as San Francisco in the United States, Weihai is surrounded by sea on three sides, facing Liaoning Penisula to the north and the Korean Peninsula and the Japan Islands to the east. It is the “doorway” to Beijing and Tianjin, thus bearing the name of “coastal front of China”
Weihai has a population of 2.5 million and a total area of 5400 square kilometers. As one of the most developed areas in north China, Weihai achieved a GDP of $8 billion and GDP per capita of $3,070 in 2001, which was the highest in Shandong Province and the same as that of Beijing.
There are four major industries in Weihai:
1. Marine aquaculture and fishery: Weihai is China’s largest base for marine aquaculture and fishery. This accounts for 25% of the City’s GDP.
2. Industrial and agricultural manufacturing: There are more than 10,000 small and medium sized companies that are engaged in industrial and agricultural manufacturing. Weihai is the largest manufacturing base for products such as tires, auto crankshafts, carpets, fishing tackle and carpenter machinery. In addition, Weihai is well known for manufacturing high-speed fax, printing machines, fiber-optical cable, polymer medical appliances, airport equipment, leather shoes, agricultural vehicles and fruit processing.
3. Tourism: Wehai is known throughout China as one of China’s premier tourist cities. Weihai has a lot of scenic spots and historical sites and received about 8 million tourists in 2002. It is extremely popular for tourism during summer time and boasts huge potential for tourism development.
4. Imports and exports: Weihai is one of the earliest trade ports in northern China. It has linking shipping service with major ports in northern China such as Tianjin, Qingdao and Dalian Ports. Additionally, Weihai has cargo and passenger ship service internationally to South Korea, Japan, Hong Kong, etc.
Question 2. How does your city compare to other Chinese cities in terms of economic development, unemployment, educational qualification of the workforce, average wages, GDP per capita and other basic measures of economic success?
Answer: Being one of the 50 cities that have the strongest economy in China, Weihai’s GDP and local government tax revenues have been growing at an average rate of 18.2% and 23.3% respectively in the past 15 years.
Since Weihai does not have a lot of state-owned companies, it has a very small number of people who are unemployed. In year 2002, the total unemployment rate is 1.7% as compared with the average unemployment rate of 3.9% across China.
Thanks to the city’s strong educational tradition, Weihai’s high school students have achieved the highest scores in national college entrance exams consecutively in Shandong province for the past 9 years. In Weihai, there are Harbin Polytechnic University (Weihai), Shandong University Weihai Campus, One Higher Vocational Institute and Higher Technical College. There are also 20 foreign language schools and many other educational training centers. Each year, there are over ten thousand university or college graduates and ten thousand graduates from vocational schools. Virtually all employees have graduated from High School or higher. As a result, Weihai boasts a high quality work force and its productivity has ranked first place in Shandong province consecutively for the past 14 years.
Finally I would like to note that Weihai has the highest income of urban residents and farmers in Shandong province in 2001. This prosperity adds to the city and has helped to reinforce the city’s livability.
Question 3. What are the major industries in your city and which sectors of business do you feel that Weihai companies both have demonstrated their ability to compete and their cost advantages vis-à-vis other areas in China? Also which new sectors do you for see generating the most growth in the years ahead?
Answer: Marine aquaculture and fisheries, auto parts industry, tourism and biotech production are currently are our key industries. We see bio-tech and the high-tech industries as being further future engines of growth.
Question 4. If you were to give five reasons for a company to consider establishing a factory or a business office in your city, what would those reasons be?
Answer:
1) Livability, clean and beautiful environment, golfing (Weihai has four of these) and other recreational sports near beaches.
2) Close to the developed economies and markets such as Japan and South Korea in North Asia
3) International ports, convenient marine transportation and convenient air access via two neighboring airports
4) Two well-known Chinese universities have two huge campuses near beaches, providing talents and trained professionals,
5) Well trained leaders at the municipal government. The city has several leaders who have studied or worked in North America.
Question 5. Weihai is located in Shandong province and I know that Shandong is a leader in both agriculture and the fishing industry in addition to having a large and well developed manufacturing base, are both the fishing and agriculture industries also important to Weihai and has Weihai used its connections through its distribution system for both industries to help serve as an export gateway to import overseas food and other items to China?
Weihai has imported a lot of production equipment from the United States and Europe and is planning to distribute salmon, tuna and other seafood to Beijing and Shanghai via its vast sales network across the country.
Question 6. I understand that your city has developed or is in the advanced planning stages of developing several incubators to help promote new industries in Weihai. Could you tell us about these incubators and your plans for new innovative means of growing new companies?
Answer: We have two incubators in Weihai right now. One is run and sponsored by the government, the other is run by a private company. Both will provide free offices for three years if the high-tech project meets the necessary qualifications. So far we have about 50 start-up companies in the incubators. With the completion of another 15000 square meters of space, we are poised to accept more start-up companies this year. An example of this is San Diego based Genway, a biotech company, that is going to move its antibody production center to the incubator in the next three months. We expect more biotech companies will move a portion of their production function to Weihai when our life science park is established here shortly.
Question 7. Your city has been named for several years as one of the 500 most livable cities in the world by the United Nations. Because of the quick pace of industrialization in China, “livable” is not a term often used to describe China’s major cities. What are the factors that make your city so suitable as a place to live and work?
Answer: There are four factors. They are:
Cleaniness: Weihai has three cities under its juridiction, all of them have received awards by the central government naming them as being “China’s Exemplary Clean Cities”.
Nice weather: Weihai has average temperature of 12 centigrade, which means it is not hot in the summer and not cold in winter. Most beach cities have high humidity, Weihai is the only city along the coast of China that is comfortable and dry.
Green land: Weihai maintains strict protection of its green belt of pine trees along the beach. It has invested huge sums of money and built many parks along the beaches and throughout the city to give the public access to green open spaces.
Key City Services: Fast growing economy, low unemployment, low crime rate, friendly neighborhoods, reasonable house prices.
Question 8. Having visited your city, I know that in many ways you are one of China’s best kept secrets in terms of both your environment and your economic viability. What is your city’s plan as to how to continue your economic development while still protecting your pleasant environment?
Answer: Promote venture capital investments, establish venture capital funds with leading venture capital companies in China, provide funding for high-tech projects from North America and Europe.
Question 9. How does the city go about competing with the bigger Chinese cities like Beijing, Shanghai, Guangzhou to attract investment and are their any upcoming plans for investment conferences, trade fairs or other venues that you could mention if readers were interested in learning more about your city and the potential for business?
Answer: We have followed policies that do the following:
• Promote the unique non polluting industries that will keep Weihai growing;
• Promote the concept of livability, create clusters of low polluting industry and attract high tech companies to establish offices, production centers and testing centers in Weihai.
• Build a convention center and develop international conferences and trade shows and continue to promote tourism.
We also are planning to host a major trade and investment conference in May for companies interested in further exploring locating in Weihai.
Question 10. If a company wanted to find out more about starting a business or building a factory in your city, what would be the best route for him or her to better research the potential? Also, saying a company wanted to attend your upcoming investment conference how could he or she learn more now about Weihai to help better prepare them for their visit and for meetings with you and your city team?
Answer: We have aligned with Runckel & Associate to promote trade and investment between Oregon and Shandong Province. You can visit the websites of both Weihai, www.weihai.gov.cn, and Runckel & Associates, www.business-in-asia.com, to find out more about Weihai or call Runckel & Associates since they are on your same time zone and can quickly respond with information and guidance.
To save your valuable time and make your visit to China and to Weihai as valuable as possible, we want to get you fully prepared before you travel to Weihai. We therefore hope to exchange information with you on many issues related to your plans for trade and investment and to give you wide ranging knowledge on potential prices of land, labor, rental, utilities and many other issues that will help you to better hone your business plan. We fully subscribe to the belief that the secret to success in business is good research and planning and we stand ready to assist in everyway possible to make your visit to Weihai a success.
About the Interviewer:
Christopher W. Runckel, a former senior US diplomat who served in many counties in Asia, is a graduate of the University of Oregon and Lewis and Clark Law School. He served as Deputy General Counsel of President Gerald Ford’s Presidential Clemency Board. Mr. Runckel is the principal and founder of Runckel & Associates, a Portland, Oregon based consulting company that assists businesses expand business opportunities in Asia. (www.business-in-asia.com)
Until April of 1999, Mr. Runckel was Minister-Counselor of the US Embassy in Beijing, China. Mr. Runckel lived and worked in Thailand for over six years. He was the first permanently assigned U.S. diplomat to return to Vietnam after the Vietnam War. In 1997, he was awarded the U.S. Department of States highest award for service, the Distinguished Honor Award, for his contribution to improving U.S.-Vietnam relations. Mr. Runckel is one of only two non-Ambassadors to receive this award in the 200-year history of the U.S. diplomatic service.
INTERVIEW WITH
FRANK JURGEN RICHTER and PAMELA C.M. MAR
Director, Asia,The World Economic Forum (WEF) and Associate, Director, China
ON THEIR NEW BOOK
CHINA – ENABLING A NEW ERA OF CHANGE

1. China is much in the news these days with articles regularly appearing concerning China’s success in attracting Foreign Investment (FDI), China’s nearly eight percent GDP growth last year, China’s exceeding a one trillion dollar figure for its economic production, etc. Was it just the fact that China is newsworthy these days that caused you to focus your new book on China or are their other factors?
China’s current newsworthiness and the book’s release do coincide. But the book has arisen out of our desire to contribute something more substantial to China’s efforts to continue to reform and expand its economy regardless of the conditions. As we say, the World Economic Forum has been in China for over 20 years, and this is just one concrete synthesis of some of that involvement.
2. This is your second collaboration and your new book is very different in organization and style from your previous book last year on Asia. You use many different techniques with a longer opening essay setting the stage for the book and your views on China, then follow with a series of short in-depth articles by noted China watchers, a section with view of current government officials, a panel of business entrepreneurs and then end with a summation and conclusion. Are you both still experimenting with your style and how happy are you both with the final book and what parts do you think worked particularly well?
Definitely each book is a bit of experimentation together with a bit of certainty. While we are happy with the result—especially the section on geopolitics and regional relations—there are always things that one thinks could have been better or that one could have spent more time on. For instance, it would have been ideal to have a piece directly addressing the social challenges facing the country. This is a book primarily about China’s economy, but within that there is definitely a social component. Perhaps in the 2nd edition!
3. In the preface of your book written by Mr. Klaus Schwab, President of the World Economic Forum (WEF), Mr. Schwab notes the WEF’s 20 year collaboration with China. Given Mr. Schwab’s obvious commitment to engagement with China and the fact that he is both of your “boss or leader” how much of his perspective and the perspective of your organization defined or affected your writings and how much of the book is truly independent?
Certainly the fact that the book is under the World Economic Forum has shaped our view of the way the country has developed. However, the effect has been very positive. We take a multi-stakeholder view of the world, and by that you see included not only government views, but also business, economists, media fellows—and from all over, too. Each are reputed in their own fields. The fact that part of the book contains contributed pieces gives space for independent viewpoints.
4. In your essay on the current state of affairs in China, you quote some interesting statistics on China’s economic development. Among them, “today over two-thirds of foreign manufacturing in China is for the domestic market.” “The second wave of FDI is characterized by a two-fold shift: from low knowledge base industries to medium and highly knowledge-intensive industries and geographically from the coastal and southern areas of the country inward.” (p. 10). These seem to indicate a less coastal bound stage of development and a more domestic as opposed to export oriented economy than most other observers have reported. Are these trends clear at this time and how certain are you of this change in economic development?
The statistics we quote are all from publicly available, reputable sources and the fact that they counter commonly held perceptions could be due to the fallibility of the latter. Having said that, we would admit that statistics only present part of the picture, and that it is necessary to take into account the whole picture that emerges, rather than just the slice presented. In this specific case, the fact that a lot of manufacturing is destined for the domestic market is only a sign of that market’s strength and size, and the collapse in global demand, especially from the first world. With regard to the shifts from low to high knowledge bases and from the coast to the inland, those are gradual trends which will take some time to be visible on a macro-level.
5. A similar statistic that seems to also indicate the change in China’s economy is noted in Fan Gang’s following essay on Reform and Development on page 35 where he notes that “the non-state sector, which consists of private companies, self-employed businesses, shareholding corporations, joint ventures with foreign investment, and community-owned rural industries, a great part of which are actually private undertakings, now contributes 74% of industrial output, 62.2% of GDP, and more than 100% of the increase in employment.” This and other statistics you note in your earlier essay seem to indicate an economy that has already transitioned much more to a private business model than most people outside of China realize. Is this change as deep as the above statistics suggest and in terms of state control of business how different is China today than many European countries in terms of state control and state intervention in the economy?
The emergence of the non-state sector is a phenomenon that has been mentioned by a number of analysts and observers. In fact the recent Party Congress in Beijing acknowledged this in allowing members of the private sector to come into the Standing Committee. This is a huge step forward, and does indicate a trend towards a more open, diverse economy. While it is too early to say, it is possible to imagine a situation in which the Chinese economy is as diverse and possibly more flexible than some of those in Europe today.
6. In your earlier piece setting out your view of the current China situation, in Fan Gang’s following article and in the article by Hank M. Paulson and Fred Hu from Goldman Sachs Group titled “Banking Reform in China: Mission Critical” all of you discuss the current weak banking sector in China but all of you conclude that although the current situation is unfortunate and even worrying, none of you believe that it will likely lead to a major banking crisis. Is this characterization of the three positions fair and if so why do your all seem so confident that the problem is solvable?
While we cannot speak for the others, we attribute our confidence primarily to two factors. The first is that the problem is critical but will only have the possibility to “blow up” and instigate a large scale collapse in the medium term. The problem is definitely fundamental to developing a healthy functioning economy, but in the short term, China can get by, by “muddling through”. The second factor is that China is doing much more than just “muddling through” the problem, by pinpointing the sources of the problem and beginning to address those, even when politically dangerous (e.g. with corruption). Recent events in China, especially in the creation of a regulatory body specifically to oversee the banking sector, confirm that China is moving in the right direction.
7. Midway in the book, Andy Xie from Morgan Stanley writes an interesting essay on the importance of enhancing competition for capital in China. In fact, he notes that this is “the last major hurdle in China’s transition toward a full-fledged market economy.” He notes the weakness of China’s current stock market in promoting corporate development and the problem with so much credit going to the state sector and sets out his prescription for China’s resolution of this problem by what he calls “a financial big bang.” Could you explain exactly what this is and whether you both agree with Mr. Xie as to the problem and as to his proposed solution?
We agree with Andy Xie that forthright action is needed to create a true market economy, although for sure people will interpret “big bang” in different ways. While we prefer to let Andy Xie elaborate further on his ideas, we do agree that coordinated action commensurate to the complex and large-scale nature of the problem is needed. Only such action will enable the government to create a financial system that is robust and flexible enough to support the growth demands of the economy.
8. Later in the book, Professor Hu Angang and Guo Yong from Tsinghua University argue that Administrative Monopolies in China are a greater danger than corruption of government officials and each year deprive Chinese citizens of much more money and create many more opportunities for corruption. Can you give some examples of Administrative Monopolies in China today and do you agree with Professor Hu as to their economic effect on China? Lastly, do you feel that the Chinese government realizes the danger and if so could you give concrete examples of how it is moving to resolve the problem?
Professor Hu and Guo Yong point to administrative monoplies as one of the drains on the economy, and in this regard, we do think that they raise a significant point. However we do also note that the government is proactively moving to dismantle these and create a more competitive framework. Its approach is pragmatic and step-by-step, and is seen in its moves to inject competition into telecom services and break up the State Power Corporation of China. These are just two examples where the government is moving ahead, and we note that it is not just the WTO
9. Philip Bowring from the International Herald Tribune sets out four issues that he feels will dominate China’s agenda in the 21st Century – economic modernization, particularly through enterprise reform, the future of Taiwan, the relationship with the United States and China’s Asian regional role. Given the fact that without further progress in the first of these issues that China’s scope for progress in the three others will be somewhat hindered, how internal focused do you see China being in the years ahead and why?
The trend today certainly seems to be of China becoming more outward looking and active internationally. China has taken leading roles to push the concept of free trade areas in Asia, and has also been a strong voice for multilateralism in the resolution of international disputes, for instance in Iraq and North Korea. It is increasingly aware of the weight of its presence internationally. Of course, like other countries, there will continue to be an extent to which foreign affairs are shaped by domestic agendas. People have said that this is very true in China’s case, although we would also argue that China is not unique in this regard.
10. Mr. Bowring, Professor Zhang Yunling from the Chinese Academy of Science and Victor Chu of First Eastern Investment group all write about China’s regional role and China’s efforts to work with Southeast Asia and Japan. To date, it seems China’s approach to Southeast Asia has had much more initial success than its “competitive partnership” with Japan. Why is this so and do you see room for optimism that China and Japan can truly come to a closer working relationship?
As Victor Chu says, the China-Japan relationship is one of Asia’s most important relationships and yet at the same time, one complicated by economic trends and historical weight. We must acknowledge these difficulties, and also realize that there is no choice but to try to focus on those areas where it is possible to make progress, and to build trust from those points. Victor Chu names several possible areas, and these are good places to start.
11. At the 2001 ASEAN Plus Three (APT) meeting (10 ASEAN countries plus China, Japan and the Republic of Korea (ROK), China and ASEAN announced their intention to establish a Free Trade Area (FTA) within ten years. Do you see such a goal as realistic and what implications does an Asian FTA have for both trade in the region and relations with the EEU and the U.S?
A free trade area in Asia would do much to solidify trade within the region and also present the region as a larger market—in consumers and suppliers—to do business with countries and firms overseas. It also makes possible the idea of an integrated pan-Asian supply chain, and could be one huge unexploited competitive advantage.
12. Your book in the section on government voices has essays by Cheng Siwei, Vice Chairman of the National People’s Congress on the need for a vibrant venture capital industry in China and from Li Yuanchao of the Nanjing City government on “Development Strategies for Big Cities”. Both of these essays are interesting. How did you decide what issues to include and what subjects to not include and how did you settle on contributors for the book?
We tried to identify key actors in policy making circles who represented different parts of the government—so for instance, central and regional, and at the central level, both Ministerial as well as from the other legislative bodies such as the CPPCC (Chinese People’s Political Consultative Conference) and the National People’s Congress.
About the Authors:
Pamela C.M. Mar is Associate Director, China, for the World Economic Forum. She has worked for a satellite television company in Asia, in rural development in Thailand and in venture capital in Hong Kong. She holds degrees from Yale and the London School of Economics and has published on China and Asian economy and business in both scholarly and general interest journals.
Frank-Jürgen Richter is Director, Asia, for the World Economic Forum. He has lived, studied, and worked in Asia for over a decade– in Tokyo and most recently in Beijing where he developed and managed a European multinational company’s China operations. An active scholar, he has authored and edited on Asian economies and international business.
Dr Richter and Ms. Mar’s most recent publication is Recreating Asia:
Visions for a New Century, which presents a wide-ranging case for Asia’s renewal in terms of regional relations and trade, governance and leadereship, globalization, and managing business challenges.
About the Interviewer:
Christopher W. Runckel, a former senior US diplomat who served in many counties in Asia, is a graduate of the University of Oregon and Lewis and Clark Law School. He served as Deputy General Counsel of President Gerald Ford’s Presidential Clemency Board. Mr. Runckel is the principal and founder of Runckel & Associates, a Portland, Oregon based consulting company that assists businesses expand business opportunities in Asia. (www.business-in-asia.com)
Until April of 1999, Mr. Runckel was Minister-Counselor of the US Embassy in Beijing, China. Mr. Runckel lived and worked in Thailand for over six years. He was the first permanently assigned U.S. diplomat to return to Vietnam after the Vietnam War. In 1997, he was awarded the U.S. Department of States highest award for service, the Distinguished Honor Award, for his contribution to improving U.S.-Vietnam relations. Mr. Runckel is one of only two non-Ambassadors to receive this award in the 200-year history of the U.S. diplomatic service.
Exclusive Interview with
MR. MIKE ROWSE, DIRECTOR-GENERAL OF INVESTMENT
PROMOTION, INVESTHK, GOVERNMENT OF HONG KONG
Question 1: As I understand it, InvestHK is the official investment promotion organization of the Hong Kong government. Also as I understand it, you play a role similar to the Board of Investment in Thailand, the Ministry of Planning and Investment in Vietnam plus similar organizations in Singapore, Malaysia and elsewhere. Could you tell us a little about InvestHK, the role of your organization in attracting investment to Hong Kong and whether you have overseas offices in addition to your office in Hong Kong?
Answer: InvestHK was established in July 2000 as a Government Department to spearhead Hong Kong’s efforts to attract inward investment. It provides information and assistance to corporations and individuals looking for direct investment opportunities in Hong Kong.
InvestHK’s sector specific experts guide potential investors thorough all stages of the investment process. We help all companies who approach us on their own initiative. When in proactive mode we focus on the following sectors :
- Financial Services
- Business and Professional Services
- Information Technology
- Media/Multimedia
- Technology (especially Electronics and Biotechnology)
- Telecommunications
- Tourism and Entertainment
- Trade Related Services
- Transportation
InvestHK offers extensive information and assistance concerning investments related to Mainland China. We maintain three dedicated teams to promote direct investment from Beijing, Shanghai and Guangdong. We also maintain representatives in London, New York, San Francisco, Paris, Milan, Brussels, Toronto, Sydney, Osaka, Seoul and Tokyo.
Question 2: Recently Hong Kong and China signed a free trade agreement. Can you tell us a little about this agreement and how it will improve Hong Kong’s trade advantages for companies that are located there?
Answer: The Closer Economic Cooperation Arrangement (CEPA) is consistent with China’s obligations as a member of the World Trade Organization. As regards trade in goods, it will eliminate all tariffs on Hong Kong-made goods exported to the Mainland in two phases (273 categories from 1 January 2004, all other goods no later than 1 January 2006). It will also provide Hong Kong companies and professionals in several services sectors with early access to the Mainland and simplify cross-border trade. Industries which will particularly benefit include management consultant services, exhibitions and conventions, advertising, legal services, accounting services, medical and dental services, real estate and construction services, transport services, distribution, logistics, forwarding services, storage services, tourism, audiovisual, banking, securities and insurance.
CEPA should also stimulate the local economy, especially the high value added manufacturing and the services sectors. It will add to Hong Kong’s advantages as an investment destination and strengthen the city’s historical role as gateway to China.
Question 3: Hong Kong was one of the first commercial hubs in Asia to see substantial investment and resulting economic development. After thirty plus years of rapid economic growth, obviously today Hong Kong is a modern city with a higher cost of living, wages and other costs than that found in much of the rest of Asia. Considering this, does Hong Kong still make sense as a location for manufacture and/or other business operation for Western companies? Also, what industries would location in Hong Kong offer the most advantages?
Answer: Hong Kong is Asia’s most international city: a vibrant, cosmopolitan community where East meets West. This produces a creative and dynamic business culture and an ideal environment for international investors interested in expanding into Asia. It is the preferred location for Asia-Pacific regional operations and a major centre for China headquarters for MNCs.
Hong Kong is one of the most open, externally-orientated economies in the world. The city is a duty-free port, where no quotas or tariffs apply. Money, goods and services flow without restriction. A strong financial system and solid economic fundamentals underpin the economy. Life in Hong Kong is based on the rule of law, providing a level playing field for individuals and enterprises. This guarantees a safe and predictable investment environment. Intellectual property rights are also protected through a sophisticated legal framework and effective enforcement of regulations.
While the manufacturing industries used to play a major role during Hong Kong’s economic development in the past, most of these operations have moved to Mainland China, taking advantage of lower labour costs. Hong Kong still retains a small manufacturing base, especially in high value-added industries, but we are now essentially a services-based economy. However, with the elimination of tariffs in some high tech sectors, Hong Kong will become more attractive for manufacturers in certain industries such as electronics, IT, pharmaceuticals etc.
Moreover, Hong Kong is home to more than 380 banking institutions, over 200 insurers, around 2100 securities dealers and about 1600 unit trusts and mutual funds. 80 of the world’s top 100 banks operate in Hong Kong.
Question 4: In the 70’s, 80’s and 90’s, Hong Kong was the centre of much of the toy manufacture, plastic molding and many other industries located there. As I understand it, most of Hong Kong’s manufacturing base has now moved across the border to Shenzhen, South China and other locations. Does Hong Kong still make sense for certain manufacturing operations and if so can you give a few examples and discuss incentives that the Hong Kong government is offering to attract investment in these industries?
Answer: As I mentioned before, the manufacturing industry only plays a relatively minor role in Hong Kong, which is now primarily a services and knowledge based economy. However, the recently signed free trade agreement between Hong Kong and the Central Government is expected to stimulate growth in certain high value-added manufacturing sectors in Hong Kong.
Unlike other economies in the region, the Hong Kong Government does not use incentives such as tax breaks or subsidies to attract international investment. We believe that Hong Kong’s advantages speak for themselves. We offer a level playing field for all companies who would like to do business here.
Question 5: Hong Kong competes directly with Singapore and Shanghai to attract companies to site their Regional Headquarters in Hong Kong. Historically Hong Kong was the first choice but has over the last several years been second choice to Singapore or Shanghai by many large multi-nationals. Has Hong Kong’s advantage as the best site to locate a regional office changed and if not, what advantages does Hong Kong possess vis-à-vis Singapore, Shanghai or other locations to site an East Asia Regional Office for a company?
Answer: The question is factually incorrect. Hong Kong is the number one location for regional operations. It is the chosen base for some 3,000 regional headquarters and regional offices representing companies from around the world. In 2002, the number of regional headquarters increased to 948, an all-time high.
We are currently seeing the weight of regional economic activity shifting to North Asia. This is mainly caused but the continuous growth and market potential of the Chinese economy, but also because countries such as Korea and Thailand emerged more rapidly from the effects of the Asian financial crisis than economies in the South. Hong Kong is a beneficiary of this trend and we are therefore in an excellent position to attract additional regional headquarters.
With China’s economy constantly expanding, Hong Kong and Shanghai will continue to play important roles in the country’s future. Shanghai is the undisputed powerhouse of China’s domestic economy, while Hong Kong is the country’s international business centre. As a result, both cities bring their distinctive characteristics and expertise to the country’s overall economic development. They are not rivals but generally complementary in an economy that will see the emergence of not one or two, but several business centres to drive its trade and investment to new levels.
Question 6: Hong Kong is known as a lower tax area and as a duty-free port. Is this information in fact true and what are the tax withholdings for a foreign corporation located in Hong Kong? Can you also list the costs of establishing a company, acquiring necessary business licenses and other procedures necessary to start business?
Answer: Hong Kong taxes are among the lowest in the world, and Hong Kong’s tax regime is simple and predictable. The corporate profits tax rate is 17.5% but the actual tax bill is often less after deductions and depreciation allowances. The personal tax rate is capped at 16%. No tax is paid by firms or individuals on foreign-sourced income of any kind, and there is no estate duty tax on non-Hong Kong assets. Basically, only company profits, salaries and property rental income are taxable. Hong Kong does not tax dividends or bank interest. There is no capital gains tax, no VAT or sales tax. This limited tax base, combined with exceptionally low tax rates, makes Hong Kong’s tax burden much lower than in virtually all other developed economies.
Registering a business in Hong Kong is a simple, straightforward procedure. All businesses need to register with the Business Registration Office and pay a fee for the issue of a business registration certificate. The current fee for a one-year certificate is HK$2,600 (US$333) and a three-year certificate is HK$7,000 (US$897).
Question 7: According to various reports including a recent article by the New York Times News Service, unemployment in Hong Kong is currently the highest ever at 8.6 percent for the period from April through June and underemployment – people who settle for part-time jobs because full-time jobs are not available – recently jumped again up to 4.3 percent of the workforce. Obviously these statistics must be of concern to the Hong Kong government. What steps are being taken to increase employment and are foreign companies who hire the unemployed given further incentives to assist their establishment in Hong Kong?
Answer: Hong Kong is closely interconnected with the global economy. As a result, we cannot escape from the effects of the current global economic downturn.
The Hong Kong government put several measures in place to assist job seekers with upgrading their skills to become more employable. It also provides short-term employment opportunities.
For example, in May, the Government put forward a package costing HK$$432 million to provide 21,500 short-term employment and training opportunities. In June, the Government proposed an additional allocation of HK$715 million to create a further 32,000 short-term jobs and training vacancies. Altogether, 53,500 employment and training opportunities have been provided in less than two months.
We were badly hit in the second quarter of 2003 by the SARS outbreak, but now this has been broughgt under control we are confident the unemployment situation has peaked and will gradually recover. We are beginning to see an upturn in Hong Kong’s economy, which, combined with the positive impact of the Mainland’s continued strong growth, should provide significantly increased job opportunities.
Question 8: The property industry in Hong Kong was long the engine of growth and of wealth accumulation. Over the last several years property values have continued to spiral downward and many individuals in Hong Kong now own properties where the mortgage amount is currently greater than the value that the property because of persistent deflation in the property sector. What is the Hong Kong government doing to revive the property sector and to stop deflation?
Answer: There is no doubt that Hong Kong economy is struggling with the effects of deflation and the ”negative wealth effect,” caused by declining asset prices. However, four years of deflation has also made Hong Kong much more competitive, which is particularly important for foreign investors. But the double-edge of the deflation sword has also affected sentiment in the general community and, with high unemployment and downward pressure on wages, it is only natural that people will feel less confident than they might otherwise feel.
Question 9: Henry C.K. Liu, Chairman of the New-York based Liu Investment Group in an article published by the Asia Times recently wrote “There is a tendency to substitute problem-solving economic measures with public relations fluff, such as “Brand Hong Kong” and “Invest Hong Kong”; as if an economy can be marketed like toothpaste. Billions are wasted to bring a Disneyland to Hong Kong on false hopes while it is well documented by now that the opening of a Disneyland theme park contributes little economically to the host community. Hong Kong cannot expect to depend on foreign investment and foreign-company regional headquarters to make it competitive. Hong Kong must first become competitive in order to attract them.” This seems very critical of Hong Kong. How would you respond to this criticism?
Answer: There is no doubt that Hong Kong Disneyland will be a tremendous asset to Hong Kong, and our investment in it a good and sound one. The millions of additional tourist arrivals that it will attract, and the tens of thousands of jobs that it will create here and in the rest of the community are but some tangible indicators of the benefits that Hong Kong will stand to enjoy.
In today’s global economy, countries and cities compete for investment. Public relations and branding are important tools to communicate the advantages Hong Kong offers to new investors. It is key to get these messages out in a coordinated and effective way.
Question 10: Hong Kong is viewed in many international travelers’ minds with SARS as ground zero even though SARS actually started across the border in China and only spread to Hong Kong later. Given the great difficulty experienced by Hong’s medical sector of doctors, nurses and hospitals in dealing with SARS many potential investors and/or tourists are wondering if Hong Kong will be struck again by SARS when the hot weather passes. What steps is and has Hong Kong taken to ensure that there is no reoccurrence of SARS and that Hospitals and the medical sector are strengthened to better deal with a potential future threat?
Answer: Thanks to the hard work and dedication of Hong Kong’s outstanding medical staff and health workers, combined with community-wide cooperation and advice from WHO and other outside experts, the SARS outbreak has been contained in Hong Kong. However, Hong Kong is not relaxing its vigilance or the strong measures that have been put in place to protect the health of residents and visitors.
As an immediate step, the Government will improve and develop the existing isolation facilities in our acute hospitals. These include improving ventilation, more individual rooms to isolate patients where necessary, allowing our frontline health care workers more room for changing and resting. The Government has reserved HK$435 million for this purpose. We are also considering the construction of additional buildings for isolation and treatment of patients with infectious diseases in selected acute hospitals.
Question 11: Hong Kong tourist arrival numbers were greatly reduced due to the fear of SARS and the reduction in international air travel. How badly was Hong Kong’s hotels and tourist industry hurt? How are current tourist numbers running and what do you think the final effect will be on annual tourist arrivals and the overall health of the Hong Kong Exhibition and meeting sector, Hong Kong hotels and the large number of service industries – restaurants, shops, etc. dependent on tourist and business travel?
Answer: There is no doubt that the outbreak of SARS was particularly damaging to the tourism industry, including hotels, restaurants and entertainment. However, in the last few weeks we are already saw a strong rebound, especially in terms of passenger arrivals and departures. Business travelers are coming back, and hotel occupancies are steadily improving. Tourists from the mainland area also visiting us again, and while we expect international tourist arrivals to take a bit longer to recover, Hong Kong is definitively back on track and open for business. In fact, tourist arrivals in June were up 71% compared to May 2003. Hotel occupancy is now over 80% and climbing.
Question 12: Your organization works directly with companies to encourage them to locate in Hong Kong. If a company was interested in further exploring locating in Hong Kong, can you give suggestions of where best they could research information on Hong Kong and also how best to contact with your organization?
Answer: InvestHK supports prospective investors with finding up-to-date market information, and we assist with identifying the right business partners. InvestHK also guides companies through the networks of government departments and facilitates ancillary services such as work visas, trade mark registration, business incorporation and countless other administrative, legal and financial logistics.
We can be contacted at:
Invest HK
Suites 1501-6, Level 15
One Pacific Place
88 Queensway, Hong Kong
Tel: (852) 3107 1000
Fax: (852) 3107 9007
E-mail: enq@investhk.gov.hk
Website: www.InvestHK.gov.hk
An Interview with Mr. Fang Youxin
Director General of Beijing Capital International Airport
September, 1999
It would be hard to find a man with more responsibility or busier than Mr. Fang Youxin, Head of Beijing’s Capital International Airport. For four years, Beijing has been involved in a major upgrade of their airport facilities and will shortly open a new state-of- the-art and much larger passenger terminal. When you meet Mr. Fang, you notice that although he is short in stature, he immediately conveys a sense of energy and leadership that mark him both as a man and a manager. Insight caught up with Mr. Fang late one evening in early September. Although it had already been a very long day for him in overseeing final details of the upcoming opening of the new terminal, VIP travel arrangements for the large Universal Postal Union conference held in Beijing, preparations for the 50th Anniversary of the founding of the People’s Republic of China and despite the fact that he had spent two nights that same week with virtually no sleep finalizing details for tests of the new terminals facilities, Mr. Fang was as always the perfect host and totally in command of all details of operations at the Airport.
Insight: Thank you for taking the time to talk with me today. I know you are very busy now preparing for the opening of the new Airport terminal and our readers and we very much appreciate your agreeing to talk with www.business-in-asia.com First, the Airport terminal is obviously much larger than the old terminal. Exactly how large is the new terminal and how does it compare to the old terminal and to other airport terminals in China?
Mr. Fang: Essentially, to date, there have been three stages to the development of Beijing Capital International Airport. The original site for the airport was chosen in 1954 and following construction opened as the capital’s first airport in December 1957. The original airport which served Beijing’s requirements during the early years had a 10,000 square meter terminal and a 2,500 meter runway with approximately 84,000 sq. meters of apron space. This was the first period. By the 1970s, it became obvious that the airport needed to grow to fully serve the nation. In January 1980, a 600,000 sq. meter new terminal building was built. This new terminal was designed to serve 60 flights daily and 1500 passengers at peak hours. Work was also done to improve the runways, support facility and air traffic control systems. This terminal served the capital and the nation well over the next nearly two decades. The decade from the founding of the Beijing Capital International Airport Administration till 1997 saw the greatest growth to date in airport operations – passenger traffic rose from 4.65 million to over 16.91 million passengers. Mail and Air freight growth rocketed to just under 500,000 tons a year by the end of 1997. By this time, however, it was extremely apparent to all that economic growth spurred by China’s modernization demanded a new airport. Therefore in 1992-3, planning started on a new airport and in 1995 construction work actually commenced. The new terminal which is scheduled to officially open on October 1 of this year will include a 336,000 sq. meter passenger terminal and 16 other supporting facilities including a 464,000 sq. meter terminal apron, multi-story car park, a cargo station and other facilities. The opening of the new terminal and the renovation of the old terminal will commence the third state of development for Beijing’s Capital International Airport, the nations largest airport.
Insight: How long has it been since your started construction and what exactly is the total cost of the new facility? Did the government provide all of these funds or did some of the funds come from the departure tax or other revenue sources?
Mr. Fang: Work on the 17 new airport facilities, which include the new passenger terminal, which is the most noticeable improvement, started on October 16, 1995. As I noted, we are already testing the new terminal by accommodating incoming and departing flights on a test basis although the airport will officially open on October 1 in recognition of the 50th anniversary of independence of the People’s Republic of China. This means that in less than four years; we have completed all of these projects, an immense improvement for Beijing and for China. Total cost of all of the construction is just over one Billion U.S. dollars (8 Billion RMB). This is an immense amount in a developing country such as China although relatively modest compared to what airport upgrades cost internationally. Less than one-third of the required funding came from passenger fees. The remainder was financed by the State.
Insight: When exactly will the new terminal open? Will the new terminal open all at one time or will services be gradually phased in?
Mr. Fang: The new passenger terminal is complete at this time and we have had two tests of the facilities using incoming or outgoing flights. The official opening of the new airport will be October 1. Our plan is to gradually phase in services in the new facility. All services will not necessarily be available immediately but will be offered as systems prove themselves and in a manner convenient to passengers and provision of all services.
Insight: Because of the delays and complications experienced in the opening of the Hong Kong and Malaysian airports, many Asian travelers are skeptical when they hear about firm dates for opening a major airport. Did you study the openings of the Hong Kong and Kuala Lumpur airports and did you learn lessons from the challenges they experienced that you applied here in Beijing? Also, could you give us an example of such a change?
Mr. Fang: We have been examining and learning from the openings of new airports long before last year and by using not only the Asian experience with this but also by looking to airport openings in Europe and in the Americas. Airport officials and myself visited Denver in the U.S. to observe the opening there and have constantly studied reports and management studies on new airport projects. We have attempted to apply the lessons learned from these past terminal openings to help assure the public of the smoothest transition here in Beijing. For example, a large part of the problem in the Hong Kong airport was with the computer system. We studied the problems experienced there and invited Hong Kong officials to visit here to allow us to learn from their experience. An additional lesson we drew from the opening of the Hong Kong Airport was not to open too soon and to fully practice with all systems. As a result, even though we could conceivably open now, we have used the time to exercise the systems to make sure that any problems are resolved before the public becomes inconvenienced. I meet daily with immigration, customs, baggage handling, food service and others ensuring that each system is tested and that all parties are working together to resolve any remaining issues. Baggage transfer systems also have been shown to have caused a large portion of the problems in Hong Kong and Kuala Lumpur, we have therefore spent much time testing our new baggage systems including live tests with flights so as to ensure that they operate as expected when the new facility is opened.
Insight: Is. Beijing, the country’s largest airport? How does it compare to other airports both internationally and in China?
Mr. Fang: Beijing is the largest airport in China in terms of passengers. In terms of world airports, Beijing Capital International Airport is the only Chinese airport that is in the top 50 airports in terms of passenger loads. In 1997, Beijing handled 141,185 airplane movements, just under 17 million passengers and 458,000 tones of airfreight. With the addition of the new passenger terminal and renovation of the old facility, we will be able to sustain future growth that would more than double the 1997 figure and still achieve first rate service to all of our passengers and airlines.
Insight: On an average day, how many departures and arrivals do you usually expect at Beijing Capital International Airport? With the opening of the new airport, will there be any increase in the number of flights utilizing Beijing Capital International Airport?
Mr. Fang: In 1997, Beijing Capital International Airport served 16,907,054 passengers, among which 11,629,400 were on domestic routes, 5,278,554 were on international routes and routes to and from Hong Kong and Macau. On average, 46,323 passengers arrive or depart the airport every day on just under 400 flights to or from about 140 plus destinations at home and abroad. Over two-thirds of our passengers are domestic and just over a quarter are international with the difference being travelers to Hong Kong and Macau. Because of the drop in passenger loads experienced by most airlines in the Asia Pacific region as a result of the Asian Financial Crisis, passenger arrivals and departures in 1998 were not as great as had been predicted. We have however seen a recovery in passenger loads as the Asian economies have started to return to growth. We anticipate that 1999 and 2000 passenger arrivals and departures will exceed our 1997 figures and that passenger loads will nearly double over the next 5-7 years.
Insight: You mentioned renovation plans for the current terminal. What exactly are the plans for the current terminal?
Mr. Fang: Our plan is to gradually renovate the current terminal and to use is for shorter-range flights. Longer-range flights would use the new terminal.
Insight: With the opening of the new airport, obviously Beijing will now have a much larger and more modern facility. In addition to more space for passengers, what new services and facilities will be available at the new airport?
Mr. Fang: As I mentioned earlier, the new passenger terminal is just one of the 17 improvements completed over the past four years. The new facility will have more apron space, a modern automated baggage handling system which uses the best available luggage handling systems, some of them from the U.S. and European countries, plus many other advances. The biggest changes may, however, be less visible. First, the new airport will have more controls over doors and access to improve passenger security. Further in a very significant change, we will be updating and modernizing our management systems. More work will be done under contract and not directly by Airport staff. Concession services, cleaning, and many other services will be awarded of the basis on open and competitive bidding so as to reduce cost, limit overhead and improve services to passengers. In essence, Beijing Capital International Airport will operate very similarly in terms of management to other major international airports.
Insight: Mr. Fang, again we thank you for the time you have taken to talk with us today. We wish you the best success in the opening of the new terminal and thank you and the many people at the Beijing Capital International Airport who will be helping make travel smoother and more enjoyable for the people of China but also for many of our readers as well.
Note: The above interviews was conducted in Chinese and translated into English.
About the Interviewer:
Christopher W. Runckel, a former senior US diplomat who served in many counties in Asia, is a graduate of the University of Oregon and Lewis and Clark Law School. He served as Deputy General Counsel of President Gerald Ford’s Presidential Clemency Board. Mr. Runckel is the principal and founder of Runckel & Associates, a Portland, Oregon based consulting company that assists businesses expand business opportunities in Asia. (www.business-in-asia.com)
Until April of 1999, Mr. Runckel was Minister-Counselor of the US Embassy in Beijing, China. Mr. Runckel lived and worked in Thailand for over six years. He was the first permanently assigned U.S. diplomat to return to Vietnam after the Vietnam War. In 1997, he was awarded the U.S. Department of States highest award for service, the Distinguished Honor Award, for his contribution to improving U.S.-Vietnam relations. Mr. Runckel is one of only two non-Ambassadors to receive this award in the 200-year history of the U.S. diplomatic service.
The Dragon Versus The Elephant:
when a company wants to move a factory to Asia

The Dragon is a symbol of China just as the Elephant is a symbol of Thailand. Our Company works in both countries and handles a number of projects each year in which clients in primarily Europe or the U.S. come to us with plans to either have a product currently produced in their country produced somewhere in Asia (so-called OEM manufacture) or to actually move a factory or build a new factory in Asia. Usually most of these clients tell us they want to go to China. The reason is that they have read countless stories of other companies relocating there or stories about China’s growing middle class and think they need to be there. Also, most of them believe manufacturing in China is the cheapest in Asia and that they also need to be cheapest to compete effectively.
In business, the customer is always right, but in consulting one also has a professional responsibility to politely point out the pitfalls and to ask the tough questions to help the client fully think through the process he or she has started. The truth is that many if not most of these companies really haven’t thought their plans through completely and that often more research is required before the best location to move a factory or to manufacture an item can be determined. This is an area in which our company excels in that we have completed projects across China and can compare North China with areas such as Shanghai, Hangzhou, Beijing, Chengdu or South China. We also are different because of our long term relationships in Vietnam, Thailand and elsewhere in Southeast Asia allow us to look at these locations and evaluate them as alternate sites as no company can afford to have all of their eggs in one basket.
Weihai, China
Recently we completed a project for a major client who came to us thinking he wanted to move one of his factories to China. Usually the first choice mentioned by the client is Shanghai. Unfortunately, Shanghai is no longer a low cost center and there are many better locations, such as Weihai in the North where labor rates are a third of those in Shanghai, land is cheaper and where there is much more motivated City and Province leaders competing for investment. Shanghai is a big modern city and the right location for a head office in China, headquarters of a world bank or business services company or a base where better infrastructure or people skills are needed, it is certainly no longer the lowest cost site in China or even when compared to many other places in Asia. I believe the situation with Shanghai is analogous to the situation in the stock market in a sense where public perception is often several months behind the market and by the time most buyers know of the opportunity and are ready to move, much of the opportunity is already gone as new opportunities develop.

Although China can be the right choice for certain projects, we believe that China is only one site to be evaluated and that there are also opportunities elsewhere in Asia. We convinced our client to look at more than one location in Asia and Thailand after consideration of Vietnam, the Philippines, Indonesia and Malaysia was selected as the alternate site. The interesting outcome of this whole exercise was the result – in actuality China was not the best or even cheapest location for the proposed factory. Thailand came out to us a somewhat surprising winner on many fronts and overall. It is a lesson that many foreign investors would be wise to note and the Thai government to better publicize.
Thailand, sometimes called the “Land of Smiles” was the hot foreign investment (FDI) site of the 1980s. During this time, many companies built factories to service Asia and to re-export back to their own country. Thailand was a first choice because of its location, stability and the long term pro-business outlook of succeeding Thai governments. Japan took the lead in this and still has a leading role in international business throughout the country. In the 1990s, Thailand’s cost advantages comparatively became less compelling and from 1997 through the rest of the century, Thailand was working off a major debt crisis that slowed business throughout the country and the region.
At the same time Thailand was stumbling badly, China was yearly seeing increases in investment and business as the low wage rate and growing consumer market attracted investors to China. Last year, China exceeded the U.S. as the number one site for foreign investment and continues to boom as America barely keeps from tumbling back into recession. Having just returned from a week long swing through Shanghai, Hangzhou, Suzhou and Weihai in China, I can hardly believe how fast China’s economy is obviously growing. This growth is an attraction for those wanting to tap the growing middle class in China but it has been our experience that most of our investors have been less interested in this and more focused on where is the best location in terms of cost, stability, intellectual property protection and tax incentives to site their factory now.
With the above considerations in mind, Thailand surprisingly beats China especially for investors who are willing to look outside of Bangkok and its suburbs to the industrial sites of Rayong and other areas nearer to the Thai coast and to shipping connections. Why is this area in particular attractive? The reason is that the Thai government has come up with an impressive package of tax and other incentives to encourage economic development and job creation outside of Bangkok and the neighboring provinces. These incentives when combined with the coming of age of many of Thailand’s better Industrial Parks such as Rojana Industrial Parks have created both the opportunity and the support structure for comfortable factory operations at low cost.


Thailand has 56 provinces and 40 of them are in what the Board of Investment (BOI) calls Zone 3. Zone 3 investments when also located in a government approved Industrial Park such as the Rojana Industrial Park in Rayong, entitles approved Board of Investment (BOI) projects lots of benefits. Here is a short table that shows how Zone 3 in Thailand compares to China in a number of areas:
Cost Comparison for Thailand and China
Factor Thailand –Zone 3 China Difference
Land Cost $30/sq meter $30/Sq meter China -50 yr lease
Land Ownership Fee Simple 50 Year Lease Thailand – Full Ownership
Plot Coverage About 85% 50-60% Thailand allows more building for same amt of land
Building Cost For Western high quality factory $25/sq ft For similar structure – $22/sq ft Slight difference in favor of Thailand
Utilities Similar Similar No major difference
Taxes Thailand offers 8 yr exemption for BOI approved projects plus 5 additional years at 50%. Further deductions for transportation, electricity, water for 10 years plus other deductions 2 yr exempt – 3 yrs at 50% Thailand clearly better
Import Tax on Raw Materials 5 year exemption, 75% exemption of imports exempt on domestic sales No Customs Duty if for Export Only Slightly more generous for Thailand
Value Added Tax 7% 17% Thailand less tax , easier on refund for exports
Cost of Fees Thailand slightly more expensive China slightly cheaper Thailand needs to reduce these fees
Unskilled Labor Thai Zone 3 minimum wage about $70/month China cost of unskilled worker $60/month China looks cheaper but required benefits actually make China more expensive
Skilled Labor Thailand competitive because of addition of China required benefits in middle but not at top China about the same through the middle levels, but cheaper at the top end Thailand more expensive for high level management, engineers, etc.
Cost of Shipping a 40 foot Container Slightly under $2,000 About $2,000 Slight benefit to China
Additional Shipping Fees Thailand Cheaper China more Costly Slight advantage to Thailand
Protection of Intellectual Property Thailand Stronger China Weak Thailand clearly stronger
Size of Domestic Market China clearly larger Thailand’s increasing with AFTA and possible FTA with China Advantage to China
Quality of Life for Expatriate Staff Thailand Offers more amenities except when compared to maybe Shanghai China Improving
Thailand provides more extensive activities
Cost of Supporting Expatriate Staff Relatively Cheaper housing, food and other costs More expensive Housing, Food and other expenses Thailand cheaper
The above figures may look surprising but they are current and based on considerable research by Runckel & Associates staff. Each project is different and we always believe that any project needs full research and consideration. Thailand is not right for every project as intensely labor intensive projects usually are cheaper in Thailand. Further, not only Zone 3 in Thailand should be consider for every project as existing factories in Bangkok or the suburbs maybe a good choice for projects requiring a considerable design component or other factors. However, the truth of the above also have been recognized by Chinese entrepreneurs such as the China World Best Group of Companies from Shanghai (a large textile and garment group of companies), that has built four factories in Rayong’s Rojana Industrial Park and currently has over 1,000 employees producing for re-export to China and elsewhere.


(Left and right) China World Best Group, Shanghai, moved its factory to Rayong’s Rojana Industial Park
The good news for Thailand is that parts of the country are as competitive as potential sites for a new factory as their competitor sites in China. The Thai government policy on offering increased tax incentives to investors willing to create jobs and increase income outside of Bangkok is a sound one. The BOI website on Thailand as a source of investment is also a winner. The problem, however, is that the BOI and the Thai government need to do more. Because of government policy, some basic items made in Thailand like plastic resin are purchased for cheaper rates in China than they are sold for in Thailand even though they are produced there. Fees for everything from renewal of work permits to licenses needs to be lessened and the application process made less costly and more efficient. BOI and Government officials need to do more to get out the good news on Thailand’s competitiveness and they particularly need to do more to convince Thai executives who are often the quickest to advise would-be investors to look to China. Thailand truly can be the “land of smiles” for newly hired workers in rural factories but government, business and the press need to do more to let the world know that Thailand is open for business and welcomes foreign factories with open arms not just a pretty smile.
About the Author:
Christopher W. Runckel, a former senior US diplomat who served in many counties in Asia, is a graduate of the University of Oregon and Lewis and Clark Law School. He served as Deputy General Counsel of President Gerald Ford’s Presidential Clemency Board. Mr. Runckel is the principal and founder of Runckel & Associates, a Portland, Oregon based consulting company that assists businesses expand business opportunities in Asia. (www.business-in-asia.com)
Until April of 1999, Mr. Runckel was Minister-Counselor of the US Embassy in Beijing, China. Mr. Runckel lived and worked in Thailand for over six years. He was the first permanently assigned U.S. diplomat to return to Vietnam after the Vietnam War. In 1997, he was awarded the U.S. Department of States highest award for service, the Distinguished Honor Award, for his contribution to improving U.S.-Vietnam relations. Mr. Runckel is one of only two non-Ambassadors to receive this award in the 200-year history of the U.S. diplomatic service.
F r e q u e n t l y A s k ed Q u e s t i o n s (FAQs)
Is Asia right for my business?
o Do you have a plan to expand internationally?
o Are you thinking of expanding your product lines and expanding market shares to some of the fastest growing economies in the world?
o Do you want to export your products/services?
o Do you feel that to remain competitive you need to transfer your manufacturing operations to a lower cost location like Asia?
o If you do not manufacture but instead source products for resale from others, to remain competitive, do you feel you have to lower your costs by cutting out the middlemen and sourcing your products direct from the manufacturer in a lower cost location like Asia
o Are you willing to put up with a time difference that may require you to work a bit later at home at night to take phone calls or answer e-mails, travel long hours to Asia, meet and work with new people.
o If you answered Yes to one or all of the above questions, then talking further with our company could benefit you and us. Runckel & Associates helps businesses do the above. We’ve helped U.S. and other companies smoothly expand their operations and we can help you.
Which companies are currently doing business in Asia?
All Fortune 1000 companies are currently doing business in Asia. Some well known names: Ford, GM, Microsoft, Wall Mart, Colgate Palmolive, Motorola, Oracle, Cisco Systems, Hewlett Packard, Compaq… but also small and medium sized U.S. companies including small to medium sized family owned companies.
Brief economic information about Asia:
China is the fastest growing consumer economy in Asia and unless conditions change will soon surpass Japan as the largest Asian economy and the second largest world economy. Some facts on China – GDP growth has averaged 8% throughout the last 20 years; 1.3 billion people; major cities are: Beijing, Shanghai, Tianjin, Guangzhou and Chongqing. Twenty years of economic growth have created a middle class in more relatively affluent coastal areas and in Major cities.
Many Chinese now have cars, own their own apartments, condominiums or houses, eat out frequently and are willing to buy western products, eat in western restaurants and shop for new products and services. China will host the 2008 Olympics Games. China entered into the World Trade Organization (WTO) in 2002. China has a pro business government and progressive economic policies that encourage foreign investments.
In addition to China, Asian economies throughout Southeast Asia are continuing to grow and expand their manufacturing operations. Thailand has over 60 million people and a growth rate of slightly over 3 percent. Vietnam has a population of over 80 million and a growth rate of over 7%, second in growth to only China in 2002. Collectively, the Southeast Asian region offers a population of over 250 million and is continuing to grow despite the current world economic slowdown. Most Asian government are stable and pro-business and all are actively seeking foreign investment from companies like yours.
Does Asia have modern infrastructure to support its economy and my investment?
Believe it or not, China has the highest number of cell phone users in the world. The quality of the phone lines in many locations can be better than those in most developed countries because quite often China and other Asian countries have gone from nothing right up to the most modern systems without the now aging equipment. Highways in China and in much of Asia are as good or better as the U.S. Highway systems, the autobahns in Germany and the cross country links in Canada and Australia. Driving from Beijing to Shanghai or from Bangkok to Chiang Mai can be just as convenient as driving across the U.S. Air transportation is as modern as anywhere in the world. Beijing, Hong Kong, Shanghai and many other sites in Asia have brand new airports. Air links exist daily to most major cities throughout the world and are on state of the art Boeing and Airbus planes. Railway transportation is quite convenient throughout Asia and China is now just starting a multi-billion dollar rehab of its entire systems. In the cities, you will see modern skyscrapers, well laid out streets and all the consumption culture with shopping malls, etc. as seen in the west. Office space throughout Asia is plentiful.
How much does it cost to start a business in Asia?
This depends totally on the type of business, the size and the goals. Generally in Asia, labor to meet highly intensive unskilled work is inexpensive. Skilled, white color workers are getting expensive in larger cities such as Singapore, Hong Kong, Beijing, and Shanghai but generally the salaries are still lower than in the U.S. or the EEU. Getting your business registered can often cost a few thousand dollars. Beyond that, it depends on how well thought out are your plans; how many options are evaluated and the particular circumstances of the location chosen. This all can be worked out with Runckel & Associates. We will work with you to prepare business plans for your venture and to ensure that your plans are well conceived, well research and efficiently commenced.
How do I get my product into Asia?
It is very important that you test your products if required and to thoroughly do your basic homework before you invest resources in a new venture. If your product needs product testing to be permitted in Asia, Runckel & Associates can let you know this and help you with several kinds of testing depending on the product you have. The process can take weeks and even a month and will cost you $2,000 or more. We can take you all the way through and provide you with an analysis and report.
Getting your company registered- Starting Your Business – Basic Principles:
o All Asian countries welcome all types of foreign investments almost across all industries.
o Getting a company started in Asia usually requires formal registrations. This can be a headache without expert assistance. With expert assistance, the process can move more swiftly and involve much less of your important time.
o Unless specially approved by local authorities, local law in many Asian countries does not recognize the forms of sole proprietorships and partnerships.
o All businesses in most Asian countries require an annual audit, which can be conducted by local accounting firms at inexpensive prices.
How do I get my company into Asia?
Runckel and Associates has extensive experience in market entry and company registration related issues. As we often get question specifically about starting a business in China, following is the basics on foreign related business structures in China. The current Chinese law recognizes THREE types of business entities that have foreign interest. These are as follows:
Type 1: A Foreign Representative Office: This was the earliest and for a time the predominant form of foreign related entity that was/is allowed to do business in China. A so-called Rep office, as it is commonly called, can only perform liaison work between the foreign parent and local businesses. A Rep office cannot generate revenue in China and cannot sign or enter into any types of revenue generating contracts with local businesses. It is solely a communications vehicle that helps its parent company to do business with Chinese clients. Advantage: easy to establish, visible and looks good; Disadvantage: cannot operate as a revenue-generating business, can be expensive and has negative tax consequences. A Rep office is like the face of a foreign company, the flashier the Rep office, the better the image of its foreign parent.
Type 2: A Joint Venture (JV) company. This used to be the predominant business vehicle for foreign companies. The foreign company provided the product, the money and sometimes the management expertise, the Chinese company provided the local connections necessary for government approval and local market expertise and the two companies split any profits. In China, a JV is a recognized corporate entity, which is a partnership between the foreign investor and the local Chinese partner. However, the JV is a corporate entity and not a partnership in the western legal sense. A JV can conduct business in China like any other business although there are certain industries that only permit 100% Chinese companies. With China’s entry into the World Trade Organization (WTO), the country is becoming more and more open to foreign businesses. A JV can enter into a vast majority of Chinese industries. Advantage: immediate market entry with local market expertise and understanding of local practice and requirements; Disadvantage: shared decision-making power, which sometimes resulted in conflict, delay or confusion. Oftentimes, less efficient use of resources and slowdown in decision making. We would recommend against entering into minority participation in a joint venture in all cases. There are instances in which the joint venture still makes sense but generally Wholly Foreign Owned Enterprises make the best sense today.
Type 3: A Wholly Foreign Owned Enterprise (WFOE). A WFOE is a 100 percent wholly owned foreign subsidiary doing business in China. This is becoming increasingly the vehicle of choice for foreign direct investment in China. The WFOE is a registered local company but the difference with other local companies is that is its’ 100% foreign ownership. Advantage: absolute decision making power, no sharing of profits, more control over company operations, can be quicker decision making, more use of western business customs; Disadvantage: lack of local knowledge, lack of local government connections, less ability to influence government permit, tax and other decisions. This can be mitigated by using expert assistance, hiring qualified local managers and building a quality staff. Runckel & Associates has extensive experience in the registration of a WFOE and we have assisted many WFOE clients in various business ventures. We will assist you determine the optimum solution for your company.
The above example is for China. Vietnam follows a somewhat similar system. Thailand, Malaysia, Singapore and to some extent Cambodia utilize more westernized business structures with definite British business influence such as the use of the Limited Partnership, Managing Directors in place of Company Presidents, etc.
How do I get a factory started in Asia?
Choosing the country in Asia to start your business and then choosing the form of your company are only the beginning. Then you need to decide on a region or a city and a site. Cost is one factor here. Also important are access to a stable source of trained labor, quality of local utilities, quality of roads and other infrastructure, proximity to ports, airports, etc. Additionally, you will need to register with required government agencies, select the right local or expatriate key company officials, file licenses, lease or build office space and production facilities, start hiring and many more issues. The decisions are many and the chance for error can initially be great until you gain experience and confidence. The old saying “Experience is often the best teacher” is true. The problem is that often the lessons may not come cheap or without a tremendous expenditure of time and delay. A little help at first goes a long way and can save you time, money and business opportunities. We are there to help.
How do I get qualified people or human resources for my planned Asian venture?
Most Asian countries are interested in foreign investment because of the fact that it creates jobs and generates income. Generally you will have no trouble finding employees. Also, to a large extent the way you will find them will be the same way you would do it in the place you are now. Want Ads, notices to labor brokers, etc. all can be effective. Additionally, you may want to look at:
1. Contacting local universities or trade associations
2. Job Fairs
3. Ads in the paper
4. Through word of mouth and upon recommendation of existing staff
12 Self-Interview : Should you be Starting a Business in Asia?
What are the Differences between Management and Corporate Structures in Asia and the West?
Where do I start?
Pick the right consultant. Use consulting service of Runckel & Associates We are not like the rest of consultants. First we have lived and worked throughout Asia, speak most of the Asian languages and understand the law, culture and challenges of living and working throughout the region. We have people on the ground in most areas in Asia and access to specialists who will put your issue first and handle it confidentially and professionally. Second, we do not seek to be all things or to accept work in areas where others may provide a better service. We will analyze your issue in confidence and if we believe your matter is unlikely to achieve the results you desire or others would represent you better we will so advise you.
o About Runckel & Associates
o Services
o Partners
What you should consider for your Asian trip?
How do you plan your trip
How do you learn more about Asia?
o Read Exlcusive Interviews About Business and Economy in Asia
o Read Books on Business and Economic in Asia
o Read Exclusive Article, A Tale of Three Cities Insight on a Business Trip to Three Cities in Asia
Useful Tools
o Export & Import with Asia – Business Guidelines
o International Business tools
o International Trade Terms
Salary rises for foreign firms continued in China


According to a new wage survey published in Shanghai recently, professionals and executives with foreign enterprises in China saw their salaries rise by nearly 7 per cent on average last year.
The survey published recently by the international Hewitt Associate Consulting Corp, included 800 foreign firms in major cities, such as Beijing, Shanghai and Guangzhou, and also many secondary cities in China.
According to Qi Xu, a senior consultant for Hewitt, only 7 per cent of the firms said salaries did not rise in 2003. Four percent said salaries would probably remain the same in 2004. According it Qi Xu, “Such a drastic increase rate is an epitome of foreign enterprises’ confidence in investing in China.” Throughout China, Shanghai toted up the highest wage hikes at 8.3 percent with both Beijing and Guangzhou following at about 7.5 percent. According to the survey, the annual per-capita income of a senior executive in a foreign enterprise in China is 645,000 RMB (approx. US$77,700). A mid-level executive makes by comparison 297,000 RMB (approx. US$35,780).
To give an example of the spread in salaries in a foreign firm in China, a professional employee could earn an annual salary of approximately 100,000 RMB (approx. US$12,000) while a factory worker or an ordinary employee could expect about 36,000 RMB (approx US$4,340).
Qi attributed the increase to “the increasing pressure on foreign firms to draw talent, foreign enterprises in China had to keep the percentage of volatile salary and long-term encouragement rewards in their salary systems.” He also stated that “The growing salaries in foreign enterprises also reflect the soaring direct investment in China”.
In 2003, despite SARS and other concerns, more and more multinational firms and global research organizations entered China. Many foreign firms have moved their China headquarters from Hong Kong or elsewhere to Beijing and a larger number are choosing Shanghai according to most reports. By early 2004, the number of foreign firms in China had increased to 468,200 with a total investment of US$953.3 billion and actual investment of US$505.55 billion.
Sourcing in Asia: China
SHANGHAI’S WORKSHOPS: SOURCING GOOD CHINESE COMPANIES IN THE SHANGHAI CHINA REGION
Shanghai is the modern, thriving hub of business in China and many Overseas companies naturally think of it first as they consider sourcing products in China and/or locating a factory there. The fact is, however, that Shanghai has already become a more expensive place to do business and although many Chinese companies maintain offices there, most Chinese company’s factories in the area are likely to be located in one of the two neighboring provinces – Zhejiang or Jiansu which border and surround China’s commercial hub.

Recently I visited Shanghai with three groups of clients involved in outsourcing aluminum fabrication, computer monitors and in sourcing plastic items.
A number of major aluminum fabricators and manufacturers make Shanghai, Jiansu and Zhejiang their home and good companies can be readily found to handle even complex projects. In terms of computer items Suzhou which is located a little of an hours drive out of Shanghai in Jiansu province is the place to go. Suzhou which is Portland, Oregon’s sister city in China has become the hub for Taiwanese and other major companies involved in computer monitor, printer and other components and is a must stop if your company is looking to source items in China, have a major OEM design completed or especially to move a factory to lower costs. City authorities are welcoming and the Business Development and Cultural Outreach city offices under Mr. Ronglong Tang are well run, proactive and can be counted upon for support with major projects.
In all of China, most first time overseas visitors fail to realize the large spaces involved or how much development has occurred already and how much is still going on everyday. China is one vast construction project with new cities, government offices, roads, housing developments, shopping centers, malls, factories, etc. going up everywhere. Air quality is seriously impaired and traffic is often dense and congested. Despite this, even in less well known locations, generally there are good hotels, safe restaurants and a warm welcome for the company interested in sourcing products or doing other projects.


A good example of the above is Zhejiang Province. As noted earlier, the province borders Shanghai which lays to its east and extends over a relatively large area which means that visits are usually best performed by air to airports in Yuanyan, Ningbo or Hangzhou. Modern highways link all of the major cities and transportation is relatively straight forward although leave some time in your schedule as factories are often a farther drive time than expected as many Chinese don’t want to disappoint or inhibit their potential buyers. Factories often will provide a car and an English speaking staff person to meet so the process shouldn’t inhibit even buyers for mid and smaller overseas companies as the process is less daunting than might be imagined. An additional advantage of Zhejiang is also that it is the site of the major port for the area which is located in Ningbo and containerized shipping can therefore be easily arranged as local transportation from the factory to the port is relatively low cost.

A good example of what Zhejiang has to offer is the city of Taizhou. Taizhou which was formed a little over 10 years ago is what is considered a mid sized city in China, with over 5.5 million people. In China, large population numbers are taken for granted and a city of a million is considered minor in Chinese terms although it would be a major city in the U.S., Europe or many other countries. Taizhou’s airport is located in nearby Huangyan which was formerly a Chinese Airbase and where some planes are still based but what now is mainly a civilian airport with several daily flights from Shanghai and other Chinese cities. The airport is about 10 minutes to the city center of Taizhou, and 15 minutes to Huangyan, the city for which it is named.
Taizhou is the largest plastic manufacturing base in China and the premier Chinese city for plastic mould fabrication. Much of this work started in China in Guangdong province when neighboring Hong Kong became too expensive but has now moved more to the Taizhou area although many of the larger Taizhou companies also have sales offices in Shanghai. Taizhou is however not just a major plastics center, it is also a major site for automotive and the automotive and motorcycle accessories industry, home and commercial sewing machine manufacture, medical and commercial chemical facilities, pumps and valves, clothing, small and family electrical appliances, food processing and for many arts and crafts. During my recent visit, I visited many of these facilities and found them modern, well run and looking for increased business.
(Picture from left: Leo Chen – Officer of Taizhou International Investment Promotion Center, Chris Runckel – President of Runckel & Associates, Jeff Bailey – General Manager of Max Packaging, Jin Yujia – Director of Foreign Investment Service of Taizhou Foreign Trade and Economic Cooperation Bureau, David McFarland – Vice President of Max Packaging , and Chen Weilin – Vice-Director of the Government Information Office of Taizhou and Director of China Taizhou Internet Information Center)
As many cities in China, Taizhou has an active office promoting investment and seeking to attract companies to locate in their city or to source major projects there. Jin Yujia (Mr. Jinni) heads the Foreign Investment Service of Taizhou’s Foreign Trade and Economic Cooperation Bureau and is actively assisted in the Taizhou’s International Investment Promotion Center by Leo Chen, a very active, well informed and well spoken official who assists foreign businesses interested in the city. Taizhou also is lucky to have the services of Mr. Chen Weilin, Vice-Director of the Government Information Office of Taizhou, and the Director of China Taizhou Internet Information Center which is seeking to bring Taizhou and its many advantages to the attention of a wider audience and support investment attraction and job creation. Together these three are ably assisted by many others who make the process of doing business in Taizhou straight forward and easy to understand.
Major industrial factory zones around Taizhou include Damai Island Economic Development Zone, Huangyan Economic Development Zone, Linhai Economic Development Zone, Taizhou Economic Development Zone and Wenling Economic Zone plus several smaller areas. I visited a number of factories located in these zones and most are located in fairly new facilities although some of those in especially Huangyan that I saw had been in operation for well over 10 years.

Although I was prepared for a Spartan hotel stay, Taizhou also has the four star New Century Hotel in Taizhou and is building a five star hotel that will open in mid-2004. We stayed in the New Century and ate at three of the restaurants there and found the food, service and facilities to be excellent. We also ate dinner at the Huangyan International Hotel which although not as new seemed well run and had a very good restaurant.
Taizhou and Zejiang province are firmly now in the front of my mind as places to think about whenever I am looking for a company to produce a product or a new area to site a factory and from what I saw the rest of the world will be hearing more and more about this booming industrial and commercial area.
About the Author:
Christopher W. Runckel, a former senior US diplomat who served in many counties in Asia, is a graduate of the University of Oregon and Lewis and Clark Law School. He served as Deputy General Counsel of President Gerald Ford’s Presidential Clemency Board. Mr. Runckel is the principal and founder of Runckel & Associates, a Portland, Oregon based consulting company that assists businesses expand business opportunities in Asia. (www.business-in-asia.com)
Until April of 1999, Mr. Runckel was Minister-Counselor of the US Embassy in Beijing, China. Mr. Runckel lived and worked in Thailand for over six years. He was the first permanently assigned U.S. diplomat to return to Vietnam after the Vietnam War. In 1997, he was awarded the U.S. Department of States highest award for service, the Distinguished Honor Award, for his contribution to improving U.S.-Vietnam relations. Mr. Runckel is one of only two non-Ambassadors to receive this award in the 200-year history of the U.S. diplomatic service.
SOURCING AND BUSINESS TRAVELLING
IN CHINA’S SHANGHAI DELTA REGION
In June 2004, I again visited Shanghai and Zhejiang province to assist clients source items and to visit the China International Consumer Goods Fair in Ningbo on June 8-9, 2004. Shanghai is a world city which with a population of over 14 million often is overwhelming. The City though is not only a “go-go” business Mecca but also a city of great parks, sights to see and fantastic restaurants, bars and entertainment locations.


No visit to business visit to Shanghai is complete without at least a short time off to visit a little of the city. Some of the sites I always try to include are a visit to one of Shanghai’s parks – I would recommend – the Jing’an Park and the Jing’an Temple. Both are central but not touristy and with many sights of real Chinese life.


I also recommend a visit to the Shanghai Museum which has a collection so large that trying to “do” the entire museum in a day will put you in sensory overload – try it instead in parts – a day for the ceramics, a day for Chinese furniture, painting and calligraphy and another sections on other days. At one-two hour “chunks”, the Museum is a much more pleasant and relaxing venue. Also, don’t forget a visit to the Museum store – it is a great location for a unique and tasteful gift.
For a different eating experience, try the Dong Bei Ren (Litterally North East People) restaurant for a fun and tasteful change. For a great western eating experience in a very unique atmosphere try T8 at the Xindiandi complex which is a great area to people watch some of the over 100,000 expatriates that live in Shanghai and the hundreds of thousands more than visit yearly.




HAINING – CHINA’S LEATHER CAPITAL
When your country has twenty-five percent of the world’s population as China does and increasingly is becoming the workshop to the world, cities can and do in China specialize to differentiate themselves and to take advantage of their specific local advantages. Although I had often heard knowledgeable friends note that Zhejiang province and the city of Haining was the place to start any search for a leather product, this was my first visit.
First, a little geography, Haining is what the Chinese term a small city (less than a half million people – although still with a population which would make it a mid-sized city in Europe or the U.S.) and is a part of Jiaxing. (A larger city of about one million located next to Haining). Haining has a number of attractive sites and is known for its tides as the Emperor was said to visit here at one point in ancient times to view the moon at this location. It is located in Zhejiang province which neighbors Shanghai and requires about a two hour drive from Shanghai to reach the city.




Haining has over 3,000 factories with the majority of them involved in the leather business. About 2-300 firms already are export qualified and items are shipped yearly to Korea, Japan, Germany, the U.S., Canada, Russia and many other locations. English language skills of some of the staff are still developing and finding a good partner who understands international business can take some work but there are several good agents working this field who we can recommend through prior experience.
Each year Haining hosts major Leather and Leather goods fair in September (the next major exhibition is scheduled for September 3-5, 2004) we were told by Mr. Anthon Huang from the Haining China Leather Market Administrative Committee. According to Mr. Huang this exhibit usually hosts up to 800 exhibitors and includes all the major quality leather goods vendors not only in Haining but from all over China. For those in the leather trade, the Haining Leather Exhibition is a very convenient way to see new products and to make new sourcing connections.


During our visit, we observed companies making leather, rabbit fur, sheepskin and other coats and jackets. We also saw companies making wallets, purses, bags, belts and many other accessories. The range of goods was very high with leather sofas and chairs, leather automobile seats and many other items also being produced at factories that are located throughout the city and its suburbs. One of these factories has over 5,000 employees but many were a hundred or less employees and were much more basic in operation.
NINGBO – PORT AND MAJOR EXPORT CENTER
Ningbo is a 25-30 minute flight from Shanghai’s Pudong or Honggiao airports. It also is a three hour drive although this drive time should be cut greatly by a long bridge and viaduct that will shortly span Hangzhou Bay from Shanghai to Ningbo. . Ningbo is a city of about eight million people. It is a major port, food processing and other business hub. Ningbo has been a major city from ancient times and there are a number of very well preserved and interesting temples and other sites to see in the city. In Ningbo we stayed at the Ningbo New Century Hotel, a four star property, in the central city that has conference facilities and a full range of restaurants with everything from Western to naturally Chinese food




Ningbo each year hosts on behalf of Zhejiang Province the China International Consumer Goods Fair and the Zhejiang International Trade and Investment Seminar. These two events are hosted concurrently yearly. The first event this year had over 2,200 exhibitors in one of the largest and a quite modern exhibition center. The exhibition included manufacturers, trading companies, e-sourcing companies, shippers and other service providers. The range of products was very extensive – everything from cars to light handicrafts with everything between. International visitors at the show included visitors from all continents – Africans, South Americans, Australians, Indian, Pakistani, Arab, U.S., Canada, Europeans and Russian with Chinese suppliers all trying to attract interest in their company and foreign and domestic buyers looking to negotiate favorable business deals.
The Zhejiang International Trade and Investment Seminar included nine cities in Zhejiang province that are all competing to attract investment and to lure new factories and other investments to their cities plus to promote international trade as a means of increasing employment and trade. One exhibition hall was set aside for these exhibitions which were highly professional and very well laid out. Additionally, each city held smaller seminars for interested investors at which they set-out their programs and discussed incentives and the cities comparative advantages in comparison to its neighbors.
TAIZHOU – MAJOR TOURIST AND INDUSTRIAL CITY


Taizhou is located a two hour drive from Ningbo and about a three hour drive from Shanghai. It is the middle part of Zhejiang’s costal are and on the southern wing of the Shanghai Economic Zone bordering Ningbo and Hangzhou on the north and connecting to Wenzhou on the South. Taizhou made up of three districts which include Jiaojiang, Huangyan and Luqiao and includes two sub cities – Linhai and Wenling. It is served by Taizhou Huangyen Airport which is modern and has flights from many Chinese cities. Flight time from Shanghai is about thirty-five minutes.


(above left) Taizhou’s exhibition area at the Ninbo’s Zhejiang Province the China International Consumer Goods Fair and the Zhejiang International Trade and Investment Seminar this year. (above right) Deputy Mayor of Taizhou greets visitors at the Taizhou exhibition area.
Taizhou is the largest base of China’s plastic, plastic mould, automobile and motorcycle spare parts, sewing machines, chemical and pharmaceutical, valves and pumps and many other industries. The city was formed years back from joining together several nearby cities into a larger urban complex and currently has a population of 5.5 million.
As most of Chinese cities, construction is taking place everywhere with new buildings being added, new roads constructed and many major infrastructure projects being undertaken. Taizhou is definitely a city on the move and you can see this in the aggressive leadership of the Cities female Mayor and its active Vice Mayor who at six foot two is a person who most people look up to.
Taizhou also is a scenic area with sites as diverse as the largest Ancient Great Wall in the South of China, Shiliang waterfall, Changyu Caves, drifting in Yangan River plus many temple and tranquil gardens tied to Confusius and Taizhou’s links to Southern Buddhist traditions in the area.
Taizhou also is served by another of New Century Hotels plus a new five star facility is set to open shortly. Restaurants specializing in seafood, excellent fresh fruit and vegetables raised nearby and many unique local products make Taizhou a great visit site as well as a good place to do business
The Purchasing Magazines: Global Sourcing Section
Buyers look toward China—but with a degree of caution One of the hesitancies: the difficulty in calculating the total cost of producing and shipping products to the U.S.
One of the hesitancies: the difficulty in calculating the total cost of producing and shipping products to the U.S.
January 13, 2005
(Source: http://www.purchasing.com/article/CA497347.html)
Purchasing professionals and supply-chain executives are testing such Chinese products as metal parts and assembly components, primarily because of perceived lower costs. But they are so cautious that sourcing is slow-paced: Only 27% of the products bought by original equipment manufacturers surveyed by PURCHASING magazine are being offshored this year in China.
That doesn’t surprise Christopher W. Runckel at the Runckel & Associates international business consulting firm in Portland, Ore. “Global sourcing dynamics are always changing and, with so many potential suppliers in one nation, a good source today may not be so good six months from now.” China already is a manufacturing powerhouse, but it remains a net importer of many manufactured products because its home market is so huge and its own industrial economy is expanding at a 14% annual rate.
Still, manufacturers of all shapes and sizes of consumer goods—making everything from windshield wipers to washing machines to clothing—are setting up factories in China despite huge cultural and logistical challenges. According to Boston Consulting Group, the average hourly pay (including benefits) of production workers in China is 80¢ versus $21.86 in the U.S. So, given the same equipment, American workers need to be 25 times more productive than their Chinese counterparts to remain competitive (excluding the cost of logistics and overseas supplier management).
But, a big issue is that China’s much-publicized manufacturing expansion has been multi-tiered but incomplete—ranging from such basic materials as cement, steel, nonferrous metals and chemicals to such finished goods as consumer electronics, home appliances, televisions and automobiles. What’s still missing, the analysts agree, is a real expansion of export-oriented commodity materials, industrial components and manufactured parts.
It is estimated that 75% of the buying groups in Industrial America are offshoring—that is, purchasing products and materials for production outside North America— to some degree. However, many of these manufacturing buying groups are hesitant to extend their industrial supply chains across the Pacific: None of the 573 purchasing personnel polled by PURCHASING magazine are sourcing the majority of raw materials there and only 10% are sourcing the majority of their intermediate parts and components with Chinese suppliers.
One of the hesitancies: difficulty in calculating the total landed cost of a product, that is, what is its true cost when logistics and delivery times are factored into the equation. In addition, they are moving cautiously because of the need to team with supply companies that have people who are fluent in English as the international language of business and who can answer e-mails, understand business principles discussed in such e-mails—and who are Internet savvy and have a professional website.
Still, numerous overseas purchasing offices are being set up in Hong Kong (to concentrate in the consumer products companies in Guangdong Province) or in Shanghai (to mainly cover Jiangsu and Zhejiang provinces with their industrial products manufacturing complexes). Economists and industrial experts say lower-end manufacturers and suppliers affected by cheap labor markets will continue to expand manufacturing in China. But that won’t happen much for higher-end manufacturers. The gurus expect that companies in the U.S. will maintain production of high-quality and precision components and parts, along with research and development, in the U.S.
Buyers polled by PURCHASING agree: Only 46% of the purchasing managers who do source in China already say their firms are building manufacturing plants there. Of those queried, 17% aren’t offshoring any of their own manufacturing to China, and the remaining 37% are only entering joint ventures in China—and there are as many of those for subassembly of parts as there are for assembly of finished end products. “It is no longer a question of if you are going to work with a manufacturer in China,” says Richard Dougherty, an analyst with Envisioneering Group in New York, “Now, it’s a matter of when and how much equity and how much co-manufacturing occurs.”
China last year shipped goods to the rest of the world worth about $438 billion; the U.S. purchased $152.4 billion, or nearly 40%, of that total. “China is turning into an attractive place for multinational buyers,” according to a report by Roland Berger Strategy Consultants that is based on a survey of 32 multinational companies. However, the products highlighted by the study are consumer-oriented: Printers, personal computers, televisions, cellular telephones, microwave ovens, DVD players, and clothes.
Most analysts note that China excels at sourcing components or goods made on templates for items such as furniture, toys, electronic components and consumer electronics, small appliances and telecommunications equipment. This fits with U.S. Census Bureau data that shows that the biggest categories of goods shipped into this country from China are clothing apparel and footwear, followed by household goods, and then toys, shooting and sporting goods, and bicycles.
The fourth-largest category—and the largest manufacturing-bound commodity group—is semiconductors, components and peripherals. The fifth-largest group of products is machinery—17 categories of durables ranging from generators, transformers, pumps, compressors, generators and electric apparatus to oil-field drilling and oil- processing equipment; from mining, excavating, paving, and construction machinery to metalworking machine tools and textile, sewing, leatherworking and food-processing machinery.
What and why buyers source
The PURCHASING magazine survey found the Top 10 products sourced from China by U.S. manufacturing buyers are completely different—ranging from metal stampings, machine-shop products, fasteners, tool and die equipment and forgings and castings to iron and steel products, plastic products, fabricated- metal products, nonferrous-metals products and electrical components.
The next batch of popular products sourced by U.S. buyers in China is builders’ hardware, machinery (in-cluding machine tools), semiconductors and other components, rubber products, consumer electronic products, electrical equipment, paper packaging materials, plastic packaging materials, motor vehicle parts, and plastic resins. The last group that make up the Top 25 are furniture, hand tools, chemicals, specialty metals and superalloys and wood products.
Actually the purchasing of materials and products from Chinese sources is so widespread that another 30 categories made the list. This doesn’t surprise analysts and trade insiders. “As more foreign companies source in China, they are challenging local factories to compete not only on price but on quality and service,” says the U.S.-China Business Council.
Of the buyers polled by PURCHASING who are offshoring from Chinese sources, 84% believe they can get cheaper goods there because of the nation’s perceived lower manufacturing and labor costs. The key reasons why buyers source in China range from their firms wanting to avoid capital investments, to supply chain groups wanting to reduce inventory costs, from obtaining procurement expertise and leverage through sourcing internationally, to using offshoring to shift cost structures from fixed to variable.
Some of the buyers also believe using China as a purchasing resource will improve their company’s time to market, help buyers obtain design and technical assistance, help buyers obtain design-for-manufacturability expertise and improve product quality. However, not everybody agrees with the idea of Chinese sourcing. “Buying from China isn’t cost-effective,” says one buyer. “The quotes I have received for custom fabrications aren’t practical, the leadtimes are too long, quality issues are problematic and the dollar saving are only 10% to 15% before assessing freight costs. China sourcing is too big a risk for too little gain.”
The ABCs of Chinese Sourcing
A. Pick product to source and define product criteria
B. Search for suppliers and research supplier qualifications
C. Evaluate samples and audit factories
D. Choose supplier
E. Establish reliable quality control
F. Establish communications
China in Major Change: Opens Retail, Distribution Sectors to Foreign Businesses
Some, including Wall Street Journal have described change as
“revolution in China’s the investment environment”
A new law which was issued in April and goes into effect at the first of June will open China’s retail and distribution sectors wide open to foreign investors. Implementation of the new law will set off a new round of faster growth in what is currently an already rapidly expanding area of the economy.
Till now, foreign companies seeking to enter China’s retail market were required to have Chinese partners to set up stores anywhere in the country. The law that comes in effect from June will mean that after December 2004, foreign companies will no longer have to meet prohibitive asset and sales requirements that had barred all but the world’s largest retail chains from entering China. It will also loosen an earlier rule that all store openings needed approval from the central government.
While the law only allows China to meet its’ undertakings to the World Trade Organization (WTO) – under which Beijing agreed to open its retail and distribution sector within three years of joining the global trade organization – it is particularly welcome to foreign investors since it runs counter to recent protectionist calls by Chinese retailers and some officials. According to the Wall Street Journal in a recent article, “It will increase the speed of expansion of the big retailers,” says Li Fei, a professor at Tsinghua University’s School of Economics and Management who was involved in drafting the new law.
In recent years, major international chains like Carrefour SA of France and Walmart Stores Inc. of the United States have expanded aggressively in China. Local Chinese retailers have loudly protested this and lobbied heavily for protection from the new competition in price and service that these major retailers have set off. Earlier drafts of the law had included a requirement for a system to rate and punish foreign retailers who had previously set up stores without central government approval. Another proposal would have prohibited foreign retailers from opening stores in cities that haven’t drawn up detailed maps of planned retail sites, which would include many smaller cities.
But the new law – which Professor Li says went through about 10 draft versions balanced local concerns by including input from foreign and domestic retailers as well as economic experts – dropped both of these provisions in the final version and appears to reflect a commitment toward a more open and fair market. U.S. trade officials say they lobbied hard to get China to remove vague and, at times, anticompetitive provisions in earlier drafts. Thy note that thee final result “shows that officials are quite determined to not protect what does not need to be protected any more,” says Allan Liu, President of the China Retail Fund, which invests in retail ventures. “It’s an encouraging sign.” Mr. Liu said.
For the immediate future, the big chains will probably be the first to benefit according to local experts. The Ministry of Commerce, which overlooks the retail sector, has begun accepting applications from foreign retailers seeking to restructure through buying out their Chinese partners, says one person who has filed such an application. Previously, foreign retailers had to operate through joint ventures. Because most Chinese companies had limited cash or narrow geographical focus, the former requirement to pair with them caused most foreign companies to limit their expansion plans; the change is likely to speed up change in a fast altering field.
In the longer term, the law also opens up a whole new area of business for smaller foreign companies that didn’t qualify to compete under previous retail and distribution laws that favored the big multinationals. Only retailers with average annual sales of more than $2 – billion (US), for example, were allowed to apply to set up in China previously. This meant in practice that only companies that manufactured in China – generally, big companies like Coca-cola, Procter & Gamble, etc. could distribute their own goods in the domestically. Everyone else had to rely on Chinese distributors, forcing companies to cede control over key aspects of business such as quality control of their products during shipment.
According to Eduardo Morcillo, a senior consultant for InterChina Consulting, now with the new law, foreign companies of any size will be able to distribute or sell goods at retail. Those likely to immediately benefit from the new policy include makers of luxury goods, high-end electronics, and industrial products, Also under the new law, foreign companies will also be permitted to import and export goods; previously they could only do this through approved Chinese companies.
“It’s a revolution in the investment environment in China,” according to Mr. Morcillo, who is based in Shanghai. “There’s a huge market for imported products, but now you will be able to import directly and sell directly.
What You Need to Know About International Banking?
In order to be a success in your export activities, you need to know how to finance your import or export and how to get paid, espescially when dealing in foreign currencies. Your banker can and should be a key member of your advisory team. Finding a bank that is comfortable and proficient in providing the various products and servcies required by exporting and importing firms is becoming easier as international sales become more and more common. The expansion of the internet and the advent of e-banking are also helping to increase the number of banks that companies can work with for their international banking requirements.
Banking Products And Services You Should Know About
Depending upon the industry in which your company operates, there are several products and services available from major international banks that can help you to get ahead of the competition. Financing and speed are integral to any sale and now is the time to look for banks on the leading edge. Multinational companies, commodity companies, capital equipment and consumer product producers are the primary users of trade financing products, which include import letter of credit, export letter of credit, stand-by letters of credit, collections, trade-related loans, structured and barter trade. The most common of these is the letter of credit. Simply put a letter of credit is a banking mechanism that permits importers to offer secure terms of sale to exporters.
In the past, most companies didn’t need to know about letters of credit. With the expansion of international trade, this has changed and even small companies increasingly are coming to utilize letters of credit and other even more advanced international financing services. Knowledge is power and you should learn about each of these instruments and evaluate if they are applicable to your particular transaction. Definitions of most of the products such as letters of credit are included in the Glossary on this website. The website www.mantissa.co.uk offers both a quick and a more extensive course for learning more about Letters of Credit and other international financing instruments. This subject is very important both for exports and imports and a visit to the website is definitely recommended.
In addition to providing the services above, companies should also expect the financial institution to be able to provide products through a web-enabled delivery portal. Many of the best trade banks are already doing this. Additionally, your international bank should also be able to offer information on the following value-added trade products and services such as:
• Prepayment and structured pre-export facilities: these services finance pre-export fabrication and provide export financing for a country’s key exports.
• Export receievables financing.
• Government-backed insurance and guarantee programs: These are available from government bodies such as Eximbank or private insurers and can help your company spread the risk.
• Programs offered by regional development banks and institutions: the IFC, ADB, World Bank, and other institutions support international sales by providing guarantees as credit support or enhancement.
• Linked exports and import financing: In some countries the export contract can act as security for essential imports. For example, in some countries that export value-added products (Asia has many), if imports (generally but not always raw materials) do not flow into the country then value-added exports stop. An international bank can credit-enhance the deal by using the export contract as security thus allowing country imports to continue.
• Global trade management: This allows you to out-source the trade documentation preparation to others who are more familiar with it and who work with these forms daily.
• Option-linked financings for commodities: Again, these are risk spreading options. Examples are trade finance solutions that have interest rate, foreign exchange, and commodity-hedging options. These can be made part of the transaction if desired.
• Counter-trade transactions: commodities, durable and other goods are essentially bartered.
• Forfeiting: This is a provision of medium-term trade finance where trade contracts are sold into the secondary market.
• Multinational inter-company structured trade/tax facilities.
Online Letters of Credit – The International Bank of the Future
For a company dealing globally, the internet is a critical tool for speed and efficiency of communications. One area where it is still in its infancy, however, has been in financing international deals. This is changing. Recently Imperial Bank launched its online SWIFTrade service at www.imperialbank.com/home.asp The site was in beta testing for two years prior to this so this is a very mature service at this point. With this service, Imperial Bank’s customers can obtain a letter of credit immediately and have it seen immediately by those who need to know about it.
The information in the system is not public and if fact most people wouldn’t have access to it. For example, the system can be kept secure by a series of passwords. In the case of imports, the importer can let the person selling to him see the letter of credit online by supplying a password; the exporter then doesn’t have to wait to be advised by his bank in his home city and can begin production immediately. In the case of fast changing market requirements such as fashion or toys, this speed can be critical. The company receiving the letter of credit can also allow others to view the document such as freight forwarders, customs brokers or other specialists, so preparation and paperwork can begin in those areas, as well.
The Imperial Bank also has an online system for financing. The importing company can fill out an application online at the website.
SWIFTrade is still being enhanced but can already provide the following online services:
• Letter of credit issuance;
• Sending electronic copies of letters of credit to the beneficiaries via e-mail;
• Allowing shippers and other partners of the company acquiring the letter of credit to have access to specific portions of the information to speed their work;
• Tracking the status of letters of credit;
• Monitor account activity, even for accounts held with foreign banks.
Opportunities for success and failure in Asia
Christopher W. Runckel
(Online source: http://portland.bizjournals.com/portland/stories/2005/01/10/focus3.html)
Asia is home to two of the World’s fastest growing economies: China and India, each with more than 1 billion in population. Asia, however, is much more than either of these countries with large trading partners like Japan, Korea, Taiwan and increasingly Southeast Asia (home to over 500 million) continuing to develop their economies and trade possibilities. Additionally, many of the trade barriers such as high import tariffs are disappearing or being greatly reduced throughout the region. Asia is currently the site of the World’s most active Free Trade Agreement environment with Thailand and Singapore both noted for their recent rapid progress in this area and now with China a significant player in the field as well.
Portland and the Northwest economically have come through very tough times. Managers have had to look long and hard at all costs and to develop creative ways to stay competitive. Despite this and the fact that Oregon and Washington State are closer to Asia than is most of the nation, many Northwest companies, especially small companies, have not taken advantage as fully as larger firms of the lower sourcing potential that Asia can offer.
Although our firm only counsels companies to look and to move jobs off shore as a last resort, often times some functions must be moved if the company is to continue to compete effectively and if jobs are to be saved here. It is with this thought that many managers and business owners approach us and in which we try to help them through our free website at www.business-in-asia.com and through our for fee consulting business.
Companies considering sourcing in Asia for the first time should heed the following advice.
Do your homework. Internet sites can help you learn more about Asia and about sourcing opportunities.
Sourcing, like any other skill, is something that is possible for all but it may be more cost-effective for you to hire someone to do the initial research as they may do this more often, have greater contacts and experience and be able to give you a more comprehensive report to work with. Therefore think about whether this is something you feel comfortable with doing and have the time to accomplish.
Sourcing need not be expensive but does involve effort, so be prepared to invest the time or pay accordingly. We and many other sourcing specialists can provide a simple sourcing report with a list of 5 or 6 potential qualified companies for well under $2,000. For this you should get company names and contact information, information on the number of employees, years in business, list of previous sales and much other relevant information.
Using a trade consultant, just as using an attorney or other professional, should follow a well thought-out process. First, you need to consider what you want to accomplish. Second, if you are going to consider hiring someone to assist you, take the time to complete a written scope of work — this need not be long, one page or so is sufficient — as to what you want to accomplish, what issues are most important to you and how broad or how narrow you want to make your search (for example, only Chinese companies, all Asian companies, only companies in a certain region, etc.)
Talk to more than one sourcing specialist. For the relationship to work, trust and a good professional and personal relationship greatly simplifies communication and increases the chances of success. Your consultant should be willing to sign a non-disclosure agreement with you in advance of any talks and to discuss your requirements in an initial consultation, then give you a written quotation noting what work is to be performed, the time period, fee, terms of payment, governing law and other critical elements of the agreement.
All consultants aren’t created equal. Get the right tool for the job. Any honest firm doing sourcing or market research work in Asia should be able to tell you where they have worked in the past, to give you references and to note areas where they have had success.
No firm is equally good throughout the region. Our firm for example has had excellent results in Thailand, Vietnam and parts of China, but will be the first to tell you that we are weak in Indonesia, the Philippines and Japan.
Even in China, no firm is equally good throughout such a large country. In the south of China, Portland companies like eBI have experience, connections and have had much success. In the north of China, other names locally would come to mind. Also, some companies are good in a particular sub sector, for example, our company has had good results in injection plastic molds and items, leather and textiles, jewelry and stamped metal items but has done little work in oil and gas, chemicals, microprocessors or high-tech manufacturing.
Use your sourcing specialist wisely. Generally the more time involved for your sourcing specialist, the more he or she will charge. Think clearly in advance whether you need help with just the initial targeting of companies or something more.
Lastly don’t underestimate yourself. Last year, thousands of companies sourced products in Asia for the first time. Most of them will tell you it was a challenging but mind-opening experience. You can do this.
Christopher W. Runckel is president of Runckel & Associates, a Portland-based international business consulting firm focused on Asia. He can be reached at (503) 244-4551 or at crunckel@business-in-asia.com.
The Preferential Policies for Foreign Investment in Chongqing cqnews.net 2003-12-05 16:29-(35)
Import and Export at the Ports in Chongqing Gained High Momentum from Jan. to May 2005-08-24
Statistics from Chongqing Customs shows that from Jan. to May, import and export at the ports in Chongqing have been increasing continuously with a total 54tons of goods in and out, among which there are 38,000 standard containers with a total value at USD980million, up by 34.9%,33.4% and 26.3% respectively.
With the increase of amount of imported goods and total values, exported made-in-Chongqing goods through the ports have increased by a big margin compared with the figure of last year.In the first five months, about 25,000 standard containers have been transported from the principal ports in Chongqing such as Jiulong and Xingang Ports.The exported volume and value are respectively 268,000tons and USD490million,up by 46.3%,43.8% and 63.1%.
The Preferential Policies for Foreign Investment in Chongqing cqnews.net 2003-12-05 16:29-(34)
Opening of Service System and Service Management Int’l Conference Yesterday 2005-08-24
International experts in service held heated discussions about the industry. Three-day long 2nd Service System and Service Management Int’l Conference began yesterday at the Economics and Business Management College of Chongqing University.
200 odd experts,scholars in service system and management from USA,Canada,France and other 21 countries attended the conference. It is said that this conference will do good to the development of service industry in Chongqing.
It is learnt that education,health care, finance, real estate business, transportation, logistics and communication industry have all been included in the service industry.In the developed countries, the turnover of service industry accounts for 70% of the total of GDP,but in China,it is only about 40%. Statistics from certain department of the city government shows that by the end of last year, population engaged in service industry in Chongqing was 544.9million, with its turnover accounting for 42% of city’s gross output.
With the deepening of internationalization and urbanization,service industry in Chongqing will be closely connected with information technologies and be more systemized. This conference will cover three topics: concept of service in cross-discipline study, service information technology and servic system study and frontier subjects concerned with service management and service system.
The Preferential Policies for Foreign Investment in Chongqing cqnews.net 2003-12-05 16:29-(33)
Chongqing Textile Enterprises Won Big Orders from Africa 2005-08-24
Chongqing Jindi Group has suffered from the Sino-American and Sino-European textile trade wars. The company has lost almost USD10million. Facing a tough export market, Jindi has successfully entered the African market. With the help of Economic Commission of Fuling District, Jindi has formally signed contracts valued at USD2million with Tunisia, Kenya and S. Africa.
The Preferential Policies for Foreign Investment in Chongqing cqnews.net 2003-12-05 16:29-(32)
Total Value of Foreign Trade in Chongqing Broke Through 2billion USD from Jan. to June – 2005-08-24
In the first half of this year, total value of foreign trade in Chongqing has reached
USD2.01billion, an increase of 13.4% over the same period of last year; export increased by 25.4% with a total value of USD1.22billion. It can be seen from the statistics released by Chongqing Customs that between April and June, export value in single month was maintained at USD250million for three months running.
Contrary to continuous increase in export, import business in Chongqing has seen minus increase for the past five consecutive months in which there was only USD 160million import in June. With highly positive increase in export and highly negative increase in import, there will be huge surplus in foreign trade in the city. In reality, surplus of the first half of the year has reached USD430million.牋
It is learnt that the decrease in the import of auto components, iron ore and steel materials was the main reason of the huge trade surplus in Chongqing. Related central government authorities began to implement the new policies such as to carry out the iron ore import permit management and to practice assessment of the iron ore import companies?quality. With that, import of iron ore and steel materials were decreased by 64.2% and 15.9% respectively in Chongqing. Since the stocked products are not yet digested and the international maritine transportation fees are going down continuously, enterprises concerned will still be on-lookers for quite some time. What抯 more, a quite inactive auto market and the enforcement of Management Measures for Auto Components Import have affected the import of auto components. In the first half year in Chongqing, we have only about USD131million import of the auto components, down by 13.6% compared with the same period of last year.
The Preferential Policies for Foreign Investment in Chongqing cqnews.net 2003-12-05 16:29-(31)
Foreign Investment Increase in Chongqing, a Sharp Contrast to the Downgoing National Scene Export Market, on the Way of Diversified Development 2005-08-24
Overall foreign investment increase speed is slowing down around the country but Chongqing where foreign investment goes up forms a sharp contrast to the national scene. In the first half of the year, the opening-up here has made great strides. Foreign capital actually used has reached 200million yuan, 36% increase over the same period of last year.
In the same period, Chongqing tried to make most of all the forces to attract foreign investment. Industrial foreign-invested projects have reached 52 while the foreign capital actually used has been USD 35.3million.
Meanwhile, export market is on the way of diversified development.Asian market is consolidated and European market and N.American market have been expanded rapidly. The role of export in foreign trade to increase demand for foreign goods has been strengthened. In the first half of the year,we have overcome many difficulties such as the upgoing price of raw materials, resources and transportation plus the further lowering of export rebate tax and tried to optimise the structure of the products: Export of electromechanical products has reached USD0.72billion, 34.1% increase over the same period of last year; Export of chemical and pharmaceutical products has reached USD0.16billion, 18.5% increase over the same period of last year; Export of new and high-tech products has reached USD0.28 billion, 29.9% increase over the same period of last year.
The Preferential Policies for Foreign Investment in Chongqing cqnews.net 2003-12-05 16:29-(30)
Guide for Approval of Foreign and Overseas Investment Projects 2005-08-26
I. Projects to be approved:foreign and overseas investment projects
II. The foundations of project approval: The Administrative Licensing Law, The State Council’s Decision on Reform of the Investment Structure, Decision on Guiding Foreign Investment, National Development and Reform Commission’s Interim Measures for the Administration of the Approval of foreign Investment Projects, Interim Measures for the Administration of Overseas Investment Projects, and Chongqing Municipality’s Interim Measures for the Approval of Foreign and Overseas Investment Projects.
III. Authorities for the approval:
A.Foreign investment projects
1. The encouraged or allowed projects with a total investment(including the increased investment,the same as the following)of over 0.1 billion dollars, or the restricted projects with an investment of over 50 million dollars shall be verified and approved by the state. The projects will be transmitted by the Chongqing Municipal Development and Reform Commission to the National Development and Reform Commission, which is authorized to approve them.
2. The encouraged or allowed projects with a total investment of over 30 million dollars (including 30 millions) to 0.1 billion dollars, or the restricted projects with an investment of less than 50 million dollars shall be verified and approved by Chongqing Municipal Development and Reform Commission and Chongqing Municipal Economic Commission according to their different responsibilities. All the projects except the industrial projects of foreign investment with the amount of less than 50 million dollars will be verified and approved by Chongqing Municipal Development and Reform Commission.
3. The encouraged or allowed projects with a total investment of less than 30 million dollars shall be handled and approved by local development and planning commissions and economic commissions in districts or counties(autonomous county, city)according to their different responsibilities.
4. The encouraged or allowed projects with a total investment of less 0.1 billion dollars in the north new development zone, Chongqing economic and technological development zone and Chongqing high-tech development zones shall be handled and approved by the administrative commissions of the zones.
B.Overseas investment projects
1. Overseas projects with a Chinese investment of 30 million dollars in resource development (refers to an investment to explore and develop crude oil, mines, and so on, the same with the following), or the overseas non-resource projects (that is, the projects of use foreign exchanges in large amounts) with the use foreign exchanges of 30 million dollars shall be reported, in accordance with regulations, by Chongqing Municipal Development and Reform Commission to the state who has the authority to verify and approve them.
2. Projects with a Chinese investment of 30 million dollars in resource development, or other projects of use foreign exchanges of 10 million dollars shall be verified and approved by Chongqing Municipal Development and Reform Commission.
3. Enterprises supervised by the central government shall be handled in accordance with the related regulations of the state if they invest overseas.
4. Projects scheduled to be in Taiwan and other countries that have no diplomatic relations with China shall be verified and approved by the National Development and Reform Commission or the State Council no matter what the amount of investment is.
IV. The list of all materials necessarily to be submitted
A. Foreign investment projects
The applicant shall submit its project application to the Chongqing Municipal Development and Reform Commission, and the application shall be done by advisory engineering bodies with relevant qualifications. The application shall need another four copies.
(I) The application shall include the following:
1. The name of the project, the period of operation, the basic information of investors;
2. The construction scale of project, the main content to be constructed, the products, the used technology and techniques, the analyses of products’ market, the planned number of employees.;
3. The location of project construction, the needed quantities for land, water, energy and others, the wastage of main raw and processed materials;
4. The evaluation of influence on the environment;
5. The estimation and calculation of prices of public products or service concerned;
6. The total investment, the registered capital, the investment amount of every investor, the method of investment contribution, the operation period, the finance plan, the import equipments and the needed amount of payment;
7. If the projects have to invite public bidding in accordance with regulations, the preliminary plan for the inviting should be provided.
The application of encouraged or allowed projects with a total investment of less than 10 million dollars can be simplified.
(II) The application shall include the following:
1. The registries (business licenses) of foreign and Chinese investors, commerce registration certificates, the latest financial statements(including the balance sheet, the profit and loss statement and the statement of cash flows), the certificates of its credit worthiness provided by the bank where the account is opened;
2. The agreements of joint venture, the board’s decisions on the increased fund and projects of purchase and mergence;
3. When a loan is concerned, the letter of financing intent, provided by the bank concerned, shall be provided;
4. The evaluation opinions about the influence on the environment, provided by the supervising administrative authority of environmental protection;
5. The opinions about the planning and the location choosing, provided by the supervising administrative authority in charge of city planning;
6. The preliminary verification opinions about the land used for the project, provided by the supervising administrative authority in charge of land and resources; or the grant contract of the use right of the state-owned land;
7. If the contributive capital is from the state-owned assets or land use right, the confirmation from relevant authorities shall be provided;
8. When the especially approved projects for business are concerned, the approval from the relevant authorities shall be provided;
For the projects to be verified and approved by the Central Government, Items 4, 5, 6 shall be provided by the municipal authorities or their superiors.
B.Overseas investment projects
The applicant shall submit its project application to Chongqing Municipal Development and Reform Commission. The application shall need another four copies:
(I)The project application shall include the following content and attachments:
1. The name of the project, and the basic information of every investor;
2. The project’s background and the information of investment circumstance;
3. The construction scale of the project, the main content to be constructed, the products, the target market, the project’s benefit, and the risk.;
4. The total investment, the investment amount of every investor, the method of investment contribution, the finance plan, and the amount of use foreign exchange;
5. When the purchase and mergence and mutual share-holding are concerned, the specific information about the company to be purchased and merged or the company to hold the shares shall be provided;
(II)The application shall include the following attachments
1. The board’s decision or the relevant decision for investment;
2. The files for the evidences of capitals, business, and credit worthiness of the Chinese investor and the foreign collaborator.;
3. The letter of financing intent, provided by the bank concerned;
4. If the investment results from the marketable securities, physical goods, intellectual property, technology, share ownership, creditor’s rights and other beneficial entitlement to property,the investment amount will be ascertained according to the evaluated value or the fair and equitable value. The application shall also contain the asset assessment statement by the relevantly qualified accountants, asset assessment bodies or other intermediate bodies, or the third side’s file, which can provide evidence for the relevant beneficial entitlement of property.
5. For the projects of bidding, purchase and merge, or joint venture, the intent letters signed by the Chinese and foreign investors, or the files like the framework agreement shall be provided;
6. For the projects of overseas purchasing or contesting for bid, the application shall include the information of the investment bodies, the background of project investment, the location and field of investment, the planned scale of investment, the construction scale, and the schedule of the project. In addition, relevant confirmation shall be attached.
V. Conditions for projects to be approved:
A.Foreign investment projects
(I)They shall be in accordance with laws and regulations of the state, Catalogue for the Guidance of Foreign Investment Industries, Catalogue of Priority Industries for Foreign Investments in Central and Western Areas;
(II)They shall be in accordance with the requirements of the development planning of the state’s economics and society, the vocation planning, and adjustment of industrial structure;
(III)They shall be in accordance with the public interest and the relevant provisions of the state’s anti-monopoly;
(IV)They shall be in accordance with the requirements of the planning of land use, the general city planning, and the policies of environmental protection;
(V)They shall be in accordance with the standards and requirements of technology and techniques, prescribed by the state and Chongqing municipality;
(VI)They shall be in accordance with relevant regulations of administration of projects and foreign loans.
B.Overseas investment projects
(I) They shall be in accordance with laws, regulations and industrial polices of the state; they shall not be harmful to the sovereignty, security and public interest of the nation; they shall not be against the rules of laws of nations;
(II) They shall be in accordance with the requirements for the sustainable development of economics and society; they shall be beneficial to the strategic resources needed for the economic development of the state; they shall be beneficial to the requirements of industrial adjustment; and they shall boost the absorption of foreign advanced technology, the labor export, and the import of technology, products and equipments;
(III) They shall be in accordance with the administrative regulations of capital accounts and foreign loans;
(IV) The investment body shall have the correspondent investment strength.
VI. The procedure for projects to be approval:
1. Application handling. The office of Chongqing Municipal Development and Reform Commission is the especial “window” that handles all the project application; the foreign economy and trade office of Chongqing Municipal Development and Reform Commission is responsible for the application of foreign and overseas investment projects. If the application materials provided by the applicant is not in accordance with relevant requirements, the applicant will be informed by the written notice within five work days since the day when the application is handled, and the written note will tell the applicant whether the application has been handled, or inform him of the materials to be added or corrected. If the materials for the application are in accordance with requirements, the supervising administrative authorities of investment shall formally accept it and provide the acceptance note. The acceptance day is the day when all the needed materials are provided.
2. Verification for the approval
(1)Experts’ advice. Within 4 work days after the supervising administrative authorities of investment have formally accepted the project application, they shall entrust, if necessary, the qualified advisory bodies to appraise all the projects that Chongqing municipality is authorized to approve; at the same time they shall inform the applicant of the time the consultation will take.
(2)Advice from other authorities. When the supervising administrative authorities of investment are verifying the projects, they shall consult the relevant authorities when supervising authorities of other vocations are concerned. The relevant authorities shall respond with written opinions within 7 days. If they don’t respond within 7 days, they are regarded to have no opinions.
(3)Hearing or experts’ appraisal. When the investment project that has a comparative big influence on the public interest is being verified, proper advisory ways like hearing shall be adopted. The project of special importance shall be appraised by experts.
3. Decision about approval. After opinions from all sides have been summed up, the decision to approve or not shall be made, and a relevant document shall be given.
(1) As to the approved project, the approval document shall be given to its applicant, and at the same time the relevant authorities shall get the copies. The approval document shall specify the construction content, the construction scale, the technological plan, the construction location, the total investment, the reasonable time limit of project, the invitation of public bidding, supervision, and other basic requirements for project supervision and examination.
(2) As to the project that has not been approved,the letter with negative decision shall be given to the applicant who will be explained why it has not been approved. And the relevant authorities shall get the copies.
VII. The period for verification and approval:
1.The projects our commission is authorized to approve shall be decided within 20 work days since the day when their applications are formally accepted(not including the time to verify and consult the relevant authorities). The applicant shall be informed in time of the decision of negative or positive approval. If the decision for negative or positive approval cannot be made within 20 workdays due to special reasons, the period can be extended to be 30 workdays after the charge hand of the commission approves it, and the applicant shall be informed by written materials why the period has been extended.
2. Projects only the state is authorized to approve shall be given preliminary verification opinions within 20 workdays since the day when qualified materials are accepted. The application materials and the preliminary verification opinions shall be transmitted to the state council’s supervising administrative authorities of investment.
VIII. Persons to contact:
Zhang Chi and Liu Yan,Tel:63899650,63899651

















